Shishkin

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от lazycat

I am always more pleased: here most active "writers" Shishkina seen only in museums and in the picture. But I have always been actively discussing it, what Nifiga not understand.

Well, that's what Shishkina with the caption "Sestroreck" tracker perhaps already inactive and even "writers".

[sergejnowo]

Сообщение от lazycat

But I have always been actively discussing it, what Nifiga not understand.

epithet "Nifiga not understand" it by itself will not mind.
It is a pity that the discussion of the originality is based only on a couple of similar epithets.
And you please make a detailed analysis of this particular work.
Analyze the composition and story, with photographs discuss the writing style.
For comparison, show photographs of works of reference (preferably from the museums)
And then we all together will dofiga understand.
A little?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от lazycat

The main thing is that work fine, Shishkin such written very much in Sestroretsk.

Yes, a lot.
But do not show you on how many of their Sestroretsk landscapes marked by the terrain, next to the signature and the date written yet and Sestroretsk. "
Not "Valaam", not "Pargolovo", not "Dusseldorf", namely, "Sestroretsk"?
I saw only one. In the museum.

Added after 12 minutes

Сообщение от sergejnowo

epithet "Nifiga not understand" it itself is not offended.

Of course, they will not.
Understand, I imagine, the quality is not innate, but blagopreobretennoe.
Maybe there gentlemen connoisseurs Shishkina podelyatsya their "understanding"?

[lazycat]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Well, that's what Shishkina with the caption "Sestroreck" tracker perhaps already inactive and even "writers".

Well, I not only about this Shishkin. The emergence of more or less seriously the author always accompanied by the text: "Yes you are mad! Well this train Polenov! (Shishkin, Aivazovsky, Korovin ...) But where did this wealth can be!"

And that wealth - and a little trolley car. Go, sell it Shishkina ...

Added after 4 minutes

Сообщение от sergejnowo

epithet "Nifiga not understand" it by itself will not mind.
It is a pity that the discussion of the originality is based only on a couple of similar epithets.
And you please make a detailed analysis of this particular work.
Analyze the composition and story, with photographs discuss the writing style.
For comparison, show photographs of works of reference (preferably from the museums)
And then we all together will dofiga understand.
A little?

The Show here on the forum, artistic calculations - is ridiculous. When every day with items such works, and look at them quite differently.

For example, Korovin Pobol I understand many of today's experts on this artist.

[sergejnowo]

Сообщение от lazycat

Go, sell it Shishkina ...

your right.
But that's the question - why?

[lazycat]

Сообщение от sergejnowo

you are right.
But that's the question - why?

And because the price of it - not three kopecks. And it's a little bit empty, not the most commercial. Yes, and ask for him as a locomotive.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от lazycat

Go, sell it Shishkina ...

Yes, this podzavis, agrees.

Added after 1 minutes

Сообщение от lazycat

Yes you are mad! Well this train Polenov!

Somewhere already heard this ...
Ah, here:

Сообщение от lazycat

Polenov as Polenov.

Сообщение от lazycat

Normal Polenov, do not listen to these gurus internet commerce.

Added after 5 minutes

Сообщение от lazycat

Well, the Germans did not believe in the authenticity of, well, thank God!

How could not believe something?
On the plate is written "Shishkin", that is, seen in photos in the message number 43.

Сообщение от uriart

All right. I kept in the archive information.
So the conclusion is.

Or is it already with the examination of "homework"?

Added after 9 minutes

Сообщение от lazycat

For example, Korovin I understand Pobol many of today's experts on this artist.

Believe in it!
I believe reading is defiantly message.

Сообщение от lazycat

About large set of standard X-rays in the Grabar - this is a funny joke? For me - ofigenno funny.

[lazycat]

Cyril Syzransky,

I'm probably the only one who then about sketch Polenova said it Polenov. Others shouted that it can not be Polenov, just because it is - POLENOV!

A medical examination on this Shishkina done after the import in January 2009. But the Germans did not believe, because they often do not believe, and little knowledge. How many auctions through their village had alterations that they be legalized?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

lazycat,

It is good that there are people who boldly and openly declare that "Korovin Pobol I understand many of today's experts on the artist"
It is good that the message of "large set of standard X-rays in the Grabar" they laugh.
It is good that they can see through the monitor authenticity "sketch" in size

Сообщение от yaks

10-16,5 see

All this is wonderful.
It is not clear to me only the relationship of such experts to other participants in the forum, not as talented, capable and knowledgeable.

[Артём]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Message from lazycat View Post
What this Shishkin not? Regular forumskie pictures from the series "do not believe"??
Where are you "joke" saw in my post?
Only a very low estimate.
And the mass of the proposals of this thing during the year from different dealers different prices.
All.

Yes normal Shishkin. Another question - like or dislike.