A. Schilder original or not and the cost

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от lasso

Here you might work in your opinion indisputable, and I saw the first two live, and despite the availability of securities of the Russian Museum in them strongly doubt. A duplicated canvas, as previously mentioned, could a long time and I do not understand that all cling to this doubling!

I know that you saw them. Cause and led ...
I like them. What are they not?
 The question of duplication, too, in my opinion, secondary.

Added after 2 minutes

Сообщение от Art-ort

well, but they convince you? "You can still search, but too lazy

And that should convince me? I have the same work resulted in proving the opposite.

Added after 4 minutes

Сообщение от Messer

Can I move the debate in another direction?
If purely hypothetically imagine that this is all the same Schilder, etc.
then offered money 20k is a good proposal?

Price is good. Give ...

[sergejnowo]

.....................

[Art-ort]

.... unfortunately I'm not collecting photos etudes Schilder which took place here and I can not upload your visual memory ... just you in this case, comparing the finished painting (smaller photo) with large etude photographed, hence the nedoverie.Preimuschestvo experts GTG and Grabar only that they have the opportunity to compare the sketches with sketches and large paintings with polotnami.A not be satisfied with a set of "well-thumbed in all editions of" illustrations.

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Art-ort

.... unfortunately I'm not collecting photos etudes Schilder which took place here and I can not upload your visual memory ... just you in this case comparing finished paintings (smaller photo) with large etude photographed, hence the nedoverie.Preimuschestvo experts TG and Grabar only that they have the opportunity to compare the sketches with sketches and large paintings with polotnami.A not satisfied with a set of "well-thumbed in all editions of" illustrations.

I brought it Etyudna work. And it is the period to which the picture is discussed. They just, well visible manner of the artist.
 
http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showpo...1&postcount=45
http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showpo...1&postcount=46

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Art-ort

This is a typical work of the late A. Schilder.

Signed ukazyvaaet that the picture painted in 1898. That is, does not refer to later, as a mature creative period Schilder (Andrey died in 1919).

[Art-ort]

at this link Your third sketch is fully consistent with that work, only difference is in a different time of day, not color
http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showpo...1&postcount=45

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Maroussia

Tiutchev, you amaze me ...

Maroussia, I am very pleased that I call you emotions. You ravish me too sometimes.

Frankly, I myself sometimes surprising!

[sergejnowo]

Art-ort, to change the terms of seats, the amount does not change.
Let him be, but as he said uriart, - The more I look at it the more questions arise



In my simple-mind, there is no sense of colonists.
Background registered almost the same colors as the front.
Completely absent, so good inherent to the author, the play of light.
Work on the perception of flat.

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Art-ort

at this link Your third sketch is fully consistent with this work, the difference is only in a different time of day, not color
http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showpo...1&postcount=45

I agree that there is something in common. But the difference is still there, too. And the big difference ...

[Art-ort]

Сообщение от sergejnowo

The more I look at it the more questions arise

This pohvalno.Kogda I rolled out about 8 years ago so his first sketch, I felt the same doubts and voprosy.Tolko we all studied the legs, feet ...