Criteria for assessing the quality of art works

[fross]

Сообщение от iosif

fross, just a good sample , when about the same thing they say the opposite.
With regard to Delphi - did not take very long ago I was in the hands of checkers >

I mean the number of views is not enough. But because you can try , and two , most importantly to provide feedback . > And ask to extend multi-criteria evaluation (preferably one >) .
And can extend the sample selected by experts at the forum. It is interesting can happen . >

[Peter]

Сообщение от fross

And can extend the sample selected by experts at the forum.
It is interesting can happen.
>

Need a specific example, a picture.

[iosif]

fross, I am beginning to think that when discussing works of art the word "test" does not fall into the category of decent > What to say about common criteria.

[Toinen]

Сообщение от artcol

And if 2 (only) the views and they opposites?

Delphi technique involves the introduction of more than two Amount of experts.

[artcol]

Сообщение от Toinen

The method involves the introduction of more Delphi than two Amountexperts.

Are you familiar with this method in practice?
Tell us pliz how you want the Delphi method to determine a masterpiece?

[Toinen]

In my opinion, this method does not work in the economy, and in art generally does not apply.

[artcol]

Сообщение от Toinen

In my view, this method does not work in the economy, and in art generally does not apply.

All right.
So expert methods for assessing and identifying the masterpieces do not work?
Or just a Delphi technique is not applicable?

[fross]

Сообщение от Toinen

In my view, this method does not work in the economy , and in art generally does not apply .

I remember how this method can be used for other tasks - forecasting in the field of sociology and politics, where the original data are similar to the task (the absence of precise criteria , the expert estimation method and the multiplicity of optimal solutions ). A mandatory anonymity and a questionnaire was after reading the results of the previous one - it's just an accelerated version of what is called a promotion . >) )

[Toinen]

There are also "One feature rating" (EXP), what else?
>

[Игорь Гурьев]

That friend, Joseph inquired about the other two art experts estimate some of the work.

This is what Comrade. Joseph is the most interesting thing in our business.
It is only necessary to make sure that art cut something in the subject.

Remember that?
"Between the two extreme views is not the truth. Between them lies the problem".

And art, as opposed to mathematics, does not solve the problem, but on the contrary, raises them.
And if you hear equally strong opinions, but the opposite, of a picture, then it is possible that:

1) The picture is anything to go by
2) The picture is worth nothing
3) it does not worth talking about.

In general, all sewn in the art of living on a thread, and if the thread is "dead", it was no one stirs.

That's rospiisi Christ the Savior Cathedral attracted various artists recognized at the time.

Siemiradzki Henry Ippolitovich received seventeen thousand rubles for one of his oryasinu there.
But this is no less than 200 thousand euros now.

But there were still artists, about whom I had not heard anything until now!
That is heard, seen, of course, read about them, but they are absolutely merciless and flew out of my head and now I'm talking about them as if I had never seen them or heard.

So, for example, restored mural of HHS, for example, no worse than those that were then written.

Just another case a bad time for art, where anything anybody does not work, no matter how hard you try.

But people also want to have their "great". Well, and have appointed them in the third third of the 19th century Litovchenko Semiradsky, Makovsky, etc.

Damn, what name of the artist in the HHS, which I do not remember sovvershenno?

Koshelev, or what?

No, absolutely can not remember.

=====

Threat
This specialist like me, never afraid to show their weaknesses.
And if it's not really an expert, it only shows all its strengths, what he knows and understands everything.
Wrap it around the corner.