Help identify the author's work

[dedulya37]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

A look at a group of riders left.

I specifically reflected the picture of Roubaud mirror to make it easier to compare with the work of sergejnowo

[sergejnowo]

Thanks to Granddaddy, I've had a bubble

By the evening I will write a detailed report, dug a lot of interesting nuances of military uniforms.

[Игорь Гурьев]

Сообщение от dedulya37

I specifically reflected the picture of Roubaud mirror to make it easier to compare with the work sergejnowo

Hm.
But the same guy is sitting.

Hence, Roubaud.

[sergejnowo]

deal with work on the military theme was much more interesting.
Etude written between 1889 and 1897. the following features:
- Round copper cookware set in 1889 and 1899 were replaced by pots of similar form, but - aluminum.
- Prior to 1897 the first was installed cap with color edging ...
Vinogradov eliminated immediately, too early for him on the one hand, and he was never spices to soldier on the other side.
Yes, he wrote and horses, and the Cossacks, but absolutely no subtleties and nuances of military attributes and uniforms.
N. Samokish harder, he of the Cossacks and wrote them brilliantly. Although in the early 90s the 19 th century, it was also for this work is still weak.
Analyzed by N. Samokish, I wonder what he wrote in the late 19 th century, only the Cossacks, and later the Whites and the Red Army.
To sketch the dragoons, to the Cossack irrelevant. Three major differences: the Cossack on the pants color stripes, checker particular sample and the specific sedlovka.
This is not N. Samokish. Later battle-not even consider.

Sketch battle-has, in comparison, their specificity. The artist was in the subject, but not an absolute expert on the uniform. Too wide a range of colors, decorations and orders on the shelves. Etude was written from life and was a benchmark for the uniforms and insignia of a particular regiment. These things just do not remember. In this case, probably belongs to dragoon the 14 th Lithuanian Dragoon Regiment.

Добавлено через 11 минут
Relatively Roubaud.
Until then, he "hooked" on a panorama, he wrote simply fantastic. An example of this work, "Living Bridge" in 1897
And since he took up the panorama, in his hand was not the brush, and roll (exaggerate). Not every detail was followed by square meter.

At auction last year sold numerous studies Roubaud from the circle of heirs. Many of them were written on the board mahogany, as discussed work. In its mass studies were not signed, but pronumirovanny on the front or back side.
That Roubaix, and none other of the discussed battle-had access in the late 19 th century to the material - he worked in Myunhine.

Добавлено через 12 минут

Сообщение от "Guriev, Igor

Not Roubaud is not Roubaud, too good for him.

The view is understandable.
It just so happened that Roubaud came once again in Munich, shortly before the First World War, stayed in Germany permanently.
During and after the revolution, Munich was the German "Mecca" of the Cossacks, or rather the white guard.
Zarabytyval, wrote in haste typical scenes on "Caucasus" "The Cossacks" to the aforementioned audience.
Quality, the details were secondary. It is these work and sales are the backbone of Roubaud in recent years.
Hence the view is not quite a high level of writing.

[sergejnowo]

[sergejnowo]

[Кирилл Сызранский]

[QUOTE="sergejnowo; 1297171]It Roubaud, and none other of the discussed battle-had access in the late 19 th century to the material - he worked in Munich.[/QUOTE]
He was in the early twentieth century, the Munich work.
In 190-1904 at the beginning of F. Roubaud in the suburbs of Munich, a group of German artists was created panorama [URL="http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9E%D0%B1%D0%BE%D1%80 %D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%B0_%D0%A1%D0%B5%D0%B2%D0%B0%D1%81% D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BF%D0%BE%D0 %BB%D1%8F_ (%D0%BF%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%BC%D0%B0) "]" Defense of Sevastopol "[/URL] , opened in 1905 in Sevastopol erected specially for her building.

[intart1]

Work at Roubaud more sweeping, with a particular style.
Here painting drier that Roubaud not very similar.
It is likely that this work of Paul Osipovich Kovalevsky (1843-1903).

[Игорь Гурьев]

Сообщение от intart1

It is likely that this is the work of Paul Osipovich Kovalevsky

Also does not seem like something.

[sergejnowo]

Thanks to everyone who participated in his time in the debate on the authorship of this work.

Slowly, bit by bit "secret" of razgadanna.

Author of - Ivan Petrovich Pryanishnikov (1831-1909), born in Sumy (p. Kuyanovka Belopolsky area).

Original name of "Trooper"