Junk or leave?

[redbor]

Сообщение от Elek; 2213651"

artist still made ​​some changes in my copy , for example, from the perspective of a man's head

What kind of changes ?
Can be compared. All within the rules.
This does not change, and minor inaccuracies copy

Сообщение от zarajara; 2214271 "

The first written in 1879 and is located in the Lviv Art Gallery. Years of writing the other two are unknown

The first 1877? or 1879 ? Mr. size 90 x 150cm. National Gallery of Armenia. ( Was bought by Alexander III)
http://www.centre.smr.ru/win/pics/pic0190/p0190.htm
 Second , in the Lviv Art Gallery. - Is repeated (1879 ?) . With her ​​and made ​​the copy .

[zarajara]

Сообщение от redbor

What are the changes?
Can be compared. All within the rules.
This does not change, and minor inaccuracies copy
First 1877? or 1879 ? Mr. size 90 x 150cm. National Gallery of Armenia. ( Was bought by Alexander III)
http://www.centre.smr.ru/win/pics/pic0190/p0190.htm
 Second , in the Lviv Art Gallery. - Is repeated (1879 ?) . With her ​​and made ​​the copy .

I just quoted . So, first in Armenia ? It is " life " in a different color scheme , more cold .
If we compare with Yerevan is not minor mistakes : the characters of others. In Semiradsky they are younger and more elegant . The characters are more similar to the Lviv Art .
By the way , we at the Academy of Fine Arts on the wall hangs a copy of the same ( one of his former students) are much better .

[redbor]

Сообщение от zarajara; 2214541"

If you compare with Yerevan is not minor inaccuracies: other characters

So we had and did not compare (although the same character in the same positions and at the same occupation ).
 A copy 'm not done with it , and with that in Lvov
http://www.artpoisk.info/artist/semi..._primeru_bogov
(the one where the other characters - in the Transcarpathian Museum and another in the Arbat is one unconfirmed authorship )

[Elek]

Сообщение от redbor

This does not change, and minor inaccuracies copy

Agree.
Now put them together, and all the simplicity and changing angles climbed out.

The impression is that the girl's mother a copy of the original.