Auction № 5 "Russian Seasons" November 23

[Анна Лебедева]

Thank you to all the participants of the discussion Bakalovich . Kirill is right about the opinions of experts GTG, because in addition to articles we have their expertise to work " scene at the fountain ." In spite of this , we will turn our attention to all opinions and is related closely to this work.

Sincerely , Anna.

[Дилетант]

Dear Anna!
 
Availability, signed by Tatyana Karpova Lvovna, removes all previous questions.
Amateur.

[Дилетант]

Lot number 59. Fedor, "Landscape with a river ".
This landscape with little change repeats F.P.Riznichenko famous painting "The glow of the sunset " in 1915.
Below - one of reproduce the original (№ 66 art series " Luban Society Islands of care for the poor ").
 Sincerely, Dilettante .

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Dilettante, 2309431

This landscape with little change repeats F.P.Riznichenko famous painting "The glow of the sunset" in 1915.

And not vice versa right?

Semen Fedorovich Fedorov died in 1910, and shown your landscape F. REZNICHENKO executed in 1915.

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran ; 2309591"

And not vice versa right?

No, not the opposite.
Given the absolute identity of " In the glow of the sunset" brush Litke Riznichenko , and the exact date of its creation (1915) and a very considerable popularity in his lifetime , is to find out:
confirmed on the basis of what belongs almost identical in composition's "Landscape with the river " brush S.Fedorova , who died in 1910 ?
Although in fact - not my damn business . Confirmed - so the base had. For Examination - complicated matter , which requires not only encyclopedic knowledge , but often included them in the conflict deep inner conviction

[Анна Лебедева]

Сообщение от Amateur , 2309611

is to find out:
confirmed on the basis of what belongs almost identical in composition's "Landscape with the river " brush S.Fedorova

On submitted work S.Fedorova a timing examination , where there is information about the preparatory drawing. I hope you it means something.
Also, if interested in my opinion on the two works, they have nothing in common except location (geographic) , on which the work. But the determination of the place, how and when artists wrote there already requires work in the archives.
Dear , amateur ! Do not cut a temper
Sincerely , Anna.

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от Anna Lebedeva, 2312731"

The work presented S.Fedorova a timing examination, where there is information about the preparatory drawing. I hope you it means something.
Also, if interested in my opinion on the two works, they have nothing in common except location (geographic), on which the work. But the determination of the place, how and when artists wrote there already requires work in the archives.
Dear, amateur! Do not cut a temper
Sincerely, Anna.

 Dear Anna,
I do not see no reason for discussion. Do not like - do not like. So be it.
Afford only one tiny point.
The existence of preparatory drawings absolutely nothing to say. No one. (And I - as well).
To use the picture as identification - a significant feature, you should determine: what and how it is made, whether he changes moments authorial compositional search discrepancies with the final (beautiful) option, what is the nature of the (free, hard, outline etc , etc), to reveal a palette of graphic techniques.
In this case, it would be bad to have samples of the auxiliary graphs supposed author. For they were masters, never work without a future graphic composition. Some artists preparatory drawing for painting not used never (K.Ya.Kryzhitsky, for example, wrote about it himself. Explain and reason). By the way, no copy without preparatory drawings I have not seen ...
Sincerely, Dilettante.

[Анна Лебедева]

Сообщение от Amateur, 2312911

I do not see no reason for discussion.

I do not see

[wasya]

Please tell me for lot 368: Tray memorable "The 100th anniversary of the 14 Infantry Regiment Olonets."
Moscow.
1898

This regimental silver?
This tray was presented to the regiment in 1898?

History is unknown or tray?
It is not clear to whom it belonged in the 19th century who was given?

[Анна Лебедева]

Сообщение от wasya

Advice please for lot 368: Tray memorable "The 100th anniversary of the 14 Infantry Regiment Olonets ." Moscow. 1898
This regimental silver? This tray was presented to the regiment in 1898 ?
History is unknown or tray ? It is not clear to whom it belonged in the 19th century who was given ?

Absolutely it can be said that the tray was made for the 100th anniversary of the regiment. Probably at his request. The remaining details of the story are unknown.