Criteria for assessing the quality of art works

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от iosif

I like, not like here is clear.

Professionals may not like a thing of any author, but if it's a masterpiece - a professional and say.

Added after 2 minutes

Сообщение от artcol

Why?

That's why the professionals, regardless of personal preference will determine the attitude of most of the audience and, therefore, of potential customers (buyers).

[artcol]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran

I would term "thought" was not used . Once this is too general for art, for art, paintings for what we think and speak right now .
Here and " plan" , and "idea" and " concept "...

In addition, the idea - it's kind of a coherent, integral sense . You can say "the idea to me in the air - worn ." Jerk . Inspiration. Etc. It still sartikulirovat necessary, transfer to language. Here , at this stage and there is a concept , idea , etc. And that would have sale.

[Игорь Гурьев]

Сообщение от iosif; 1935251"

was the question of the opposite opinion of two professionals . Like - dislike , everything is clear. But the assessment of professionals on the subject of monetary value , in theory, should not differ fundamentally .

Let the other examples.
You see, here is a poet Selvinsky quite professional .
In my opinion, he guano . Because at heart he was - a slave.
And someone like that.

From a recent history of art stuff Goncharova nothing of myself do not represent , but in terms of materalnoy - do so, represent.

Painting Serov , " The Rape of Europa " was bought 15 years ago for 0.5 dollars a lemon - and it seemed a huge price .
Now it's worth, perhaps , ten times more expensive.

Some critics to Segantini - a slight artist, but worth it - hoo .

Nalbandian. From the point of painting - the third grade , but the paintings are , and to 20 thousand dollars.

Turzhansky . Fine artist , but completely misunderstood the collecting community.

And tagdalie .

[iosif]

artcol, because that is the subject of the market, and both an art expert - professionals in this market.

[artcol]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran

That's why the professionals , regardless of personal preference will determine the attitude of most of the audience and, therefore, of potential customers (buyers ).

I agree . Market valuation is almost entirely dependent on demand. And artistic evaluation is in principle only the starting position , and then - purely market . You want to say this , Cyril ?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от artcol

Furthermore, the idea - it's kind of a coherent, integral sense . You can say "the idea to me in the air - worn ." Jerk . Inspiration. Etc. It still sartikulirovat necessary, transfer to language. Here , at this stage and there is a concept , idea , etc. And that would have sale.

I mean, that any call for comment structuring even used terms.
What could be there to bring a clear simple formula.

[artcol]

Сообщение от iosif

artcol, because that is the subject of the market, and both an art expert - professionals in this market.

both an art expert - also subjects of this market.

[Игорь Гурьев]

Сообщение от iosif; 1935351"

both an art expert - professionals in this market.

The word "professional" - are generally pretty stupid .

Experts call each other specialists, rather than the " professionals" .

In general, art specialists assigned to other price than the market .
But the market - he's a fool , like an unreasonable calves: Collectors often important story, and , as they say , the image of a horse is preferable to cow's image and the image is preferable to young aunties pictures homeless .
This if the first approximation.

Repin painting , " In conclusion " was not bought at the Christie's /Sotheby's because you know what? Yes PLOT !

[iosif]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran

Professional may not like a thing of any author, but if it's a masterpiece - a professional and say.

[color="#666686 " ]Added after 2 minutes[/color]

That's why the professionals , regardless of personal preference will determine the attitude of most of the audience and, therefore, of potential customers (buyers ).

Here is a former math becomes easier > Both phrases strongly reduce cognitive confusion .
However, one small hitch , I have already mentioned . What was said about the pros Cezanne ? And, even more after the recognition of other Impressionists.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от artcol

Do you want to say this, Cyril?

No, I would say that - he said.

Is where not clear my mind, it requires some comment?
>