Experts in Goncharova, what do you think?

[OlegTsi]

Сообщение от sem21; 1933471"

found here Goncharova one picture at Auction

Сообщение от sem21; 1936111"

Thank you for all statements ..... But now I do not buy this , it was bought by my friend in America , and bragged to me ! I just wanted to know what the experts think about it !!!!!!

Be sure to advise your friend to read this forum.
Do not ever write a message of false information.

First, there are a lot of serious people with extensive information and knowledge.
Second, sooner or later , all the same is not true crawls out, like an awl from a bag .
Third, do not fall under the impact bombardment .

[redbor]

Сообщение от sem21

my friend bought it in America, and bragged to me!

Well, properly purchased, 13 000, not money, but the picture in any case, about a hundred years.
On the edge, can claim to show Leslie Hindman.

But in general, why Goncharov?
Just sign in Latin?

[Toinen]

Сообщение от redbor

Actually, why Goncharov?
There's a signature, whether that is?

In the lower right corner.

[Игорь Гурьев]

Comrade Oleg Ji.
Chi- san!

Let's be honest and without equivocation .
You've seen pictures of Goncharova after 1919 , comparable to 1909-1913 years , say ?

I anticipate a question: are you?
I ?
No, I did not see.
And I think I see .
Graphics - yet here and there, but the painting?

That's because this is quite simple falshakodelatelyam mislead the simple and honest citizens.

I do not know how you and I have just depressuha when I see things Goncharova after 1919 ( approximately ) of the year .
Colors are dirty, stupid , prozrachnovatye , composition barely holds on.
Well tagdalie .

No, but really , you've seen things Goncharova since 1920 more or less decent ?

[sem21]

Сообщение от OlegTsi

Be sure to advise your friend to read this forum.
Do not ever write a message of false information.

First, there are a lot of serious people with extensive information and knowledge.
Second, sooner or later , all the same is not true crawls out, like an awl from a bag .
Third, do not fall under the impact bombardment .

Thank you ... Uchtu ! !

[redbor]

By the way, here, is not a bad watercolor Natalia Goncharova (Signature NG)
 
In 2005, the proposed Christie's.

Watercolor on paper.
See 35h27

While the price of just $ 4,200, with a successful scenario has a chance to earn good money.

[Toinen]

Сообщение от redbor

with a successful scenario has a chance to make good money

Many opportunities to make money!
And every year these opportunities are becoming more and more!

[OlegTsi]

Сообщение от Igor Guryev; 1936471"

Have you seen pictures of Goncharova after 1919, comparable to the 1909-1913 years

Why do they compare? Are you a movie compares with the 1910 movie 90? It is not necessary.

My life, age, peace, people, environment, fashion, trends and fans.
Remain in the old - so do not grow. We do not have to choose the fate of artists and creative direction of the ancient times, and only to them. Yes, and did not need the Cubists after 20s. In Cubism continued to work just ... poddelschiki.

Goncharova in 1914 worked in ballet than earning a living. With 20 immigrated to the city of P. It is often returned to the elements of cubism, Rayonism, neo-primitivism, but was looking for myself in neoclassicism. John Boult says that in the 20's Goncharov copied elements in pre-revolutionary works, and even changed the whole pieces of art.

Сообщение от Igor Guryev; 1936471"

well, though, you've seen things Goncharova since 1920 more or less decent?

Comparison of the art - is subjective. What I like may not like you, Guriev, Igor.
Here are a few photos, which show close interweaving of art style of 10th. there from 19-20 before 1958.

PS. This is my third attempt to answer all of the time there. failures, so from my treatise with only 10%of the text. third time to rewrite the same thing did not ...

[OlegTsi]

Сообщение от redbor; 1936951"

By the way , that's too bad watercolor Natalia Goncharova (Signature NG)
In 2005, the proposed Christie's.
Watercolor on paper . 35h27 see

This watercolor has found peace in " Fakes Fakes ... ..."

Auction Bill Hood & Sons Art & Antique Auctions sold it a few times.

In August 2011 the assessment of 500-800 dollars she left behind 475 dollars, and in December 2011 it was sold for 150 dollars ! >

Attributed to Natalia Sergeevna Goncharova

Bill Hood & Sons Art & Antique ..

Sold For $ 150

6th Dec 11 Lot#181B

Today she Ibee .

[Игорь Гурьев]

Сообщение от OlegTsi; 1937191"

Why do they compare ? Are you a movie compares with the 1910 movie 90 ? It is not necessary.

We must , we must compare.
The works of Matisse 1920-1930 's - not like in the early centuries, but also excellent.
Things Pavel Kuznetsov also excellent.
I can list goes on. This can come in and Konchalovsky, and Derain, Rouault , and , and mango, and Nolde, Kirchner, and , yes you never know who ...

But a comrade . Goncharova - a sharp decline in the level of skill.
Depressing ...
You do not agree ?