Продам: Saryan, 1911, expert opinion from the State Tretyakov Gallery

[Seriy]

In America, too, must answer for everything, and nowhere to hide. There for moral damages may be awarded millions. So sell in Russia.

[мистер-у]

Сообщение от Seriy

In America, too, must answer for everything, and nowhere to hide. There for moral damages may be awarded millions. So sell in Russia.

And we prosche.Nam do not need millions of them, but these vendors have them and can not byt.Nam need another one word swindler should be punished and the punishment we order ourselves.

[Tana]

Сообщение от uriart

We have a good start.
Oleg Qi, a big thanks to him!
With his light hand, I got rid of the false Burliuk purchased at Christie's. Money has already returned. Deploying photo real work and falshaka which was sold at Christie's.
If every little bit will remove trash from commercial areas, so it will be the same cleaner! And nicer!

uriart I want to congratulate you with this, because not so often manage to return falshak!
uriart, can you ask to tell the story of the return to a particular topic of forgery (if possible), I will be very grateful.

[uriart]

Tana, history is very simple.
I bought on internet auction and because of ignorance of the language (English) are not lifted the box with this lot when buying another painting. It turned out that he bought two. Not really worried, it was hot. Thought that someone selling. So I hung this work.
I have posted the photo in my album here on the site.
Oleg has seen my photo and wrote me and sent photos of the original which was filmed copy.
Then I wrote a letter to Christie and sent them both the photo and asked that as such can byt.Proshlo of 2 years from the date of purchase, and Christie provide guarantees for five years.
They demanded to send them now. I sent a month later and with a little money back to me 15 000 dollars.
That's the whole story.
Since Christie's of London, I had a different situation, but it uzhu another story.

The trouble in our mentality. We're basically pro-Soviet (I'm so sure!).
Not in the sense that I sovdepovets, but the fact that the Council of Deputies looking for foreigners with aspiration and believed that there are all very honest people!
How do you know that the percentage of honest and dishonest people varies in different countries. Where it is more and where less is a subject for research sociologists.
A rogues of all stripes have enough everywhere!
One must be cautious and not very all doveryat.Eto I have concluded for themselves and recommend to others!

[Romario]

Сообщение от uriart

Of course terrible, when close to normal.

but by itself I did not like the picture, without any close
Forgive me, I express my art ichsklyuchitelno amateur opinion - like \\\\ dislike

[Alkalan]

James D. Julia, Fairfield, Maine
USA 04937
Auction: February 4 & 5 2-Day Winter Antiques & Fine Art Auction
http://www.juliaauctions.com/auction....asp?pageREQ=1
Lot number 1169 regular Saryan, and a lot of things like product.

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Alenka

interplay prove that you are very clever and can determine the authenticity of the paintings are not holding it in his hands. Good luck.

Why do not do this if possible? It sometimes happens that the photo can not do it, but it happens that you can! I, for example, a child could not even imagine what will be possible such things as cell phone and internet! And now it is commonplace ... Examination on the internet? Why not, if it brings results?

Сообщение от Alenka

How zameteli, no self-respecting judge would not issue a confirmation of authenticity on the internet, not holding a picture in his hands (Quote not literally - but then, God forbid, yet somehow be blamed), the forum welcome molneinosnoe charges of fraud, deception, etc. - Obtain the complete contradiction to themselves.

The Forum welcomed, though as elsewhere where professionals meet, exchange experiences and information! If you have something to argue on the merits, then welcome!

[Евгений]

Сообщение от Tjutchev

Despite the expertise Hoffman and Lomize, I can not make myself believe that this work Saryan.

 

Сообщение от Samvel

Dear Alenka, except for chem. analysis, there are many wonderful things (factors) on examination of paintings by M. Saryan, which is not you, not "Assi" on a fake not vkurse. I want one of these secrets to reveal, to the master of fake pictures too did not work. The fact that Martiros s1907 to 1914 led the notebook-diary detailing all their zapisoval sold and donated works, so that no new unknown paintings of this period, when they appear not one himself a respected expert not confirmed.
P.S. You exhibited works, among saryanovskih falshakov can zanemat high places

Given the information the distinguished collector Samvel O., we can assume that this work with great probability, is also a fake works of M. Saryan ...
-------------------------------------------------- -------

Читать дальше... 

Сообщение от Tjutchev

Lomize,

On the "expertise" I. Lomize written and more than once:
".... Also in the catalog (Catalog fakes ,1-4 volume) carried an interview of one of the biggest collectors in Russia, Alfa Bank president Pyotr Aven, which he gave the publisher of the directory also collector Vladimir Roshchin. The essence of his in the literal and sharp indictment Russian experts and Russian antiquities market in the uncleanliness and corruption. "I believe that we should not hesitate to name names - says Peter Aven, - Here are the experts GTG Valyaeva or Lomize. They are very few people trust ......"
http://www.kommersant.ru/doc.aspx?Do...6&ThemesID=183
----------------------------------------------
Here's another fake with the "expertise" I. Lomize

Сообщение от Oleg Nazarov

That's a fake Saryan with original papers from the State Tretyakov Gallery .... signature too real .... weak odd job, can be seen as zastaren canvas etc. ...
I saw her in the 2008m, but probably now somewhere wandering hand