N. N. Karasin (1842-1908)

[P_Anna]

Grif, You attentive itself not once looked at the work, but never saw such a sad posture of the horse. Really...if it caves in..)
However, I understand it is the very work on earth, sometimes feel like a horse, and the legs do not hold)))

[Гриф]

Сообщение от P_Anna

and work, but never saw such a sad posture of the horse. Really

Alas. Now this is why I don't like. Including on this forum. Spices always a shame when "Amateur" sees what they do not see, in spite of years of study and experience.

I again suggest you to contact the experts. See, if you wrote "master", those who work with horses will see many interesting things. The approximate age of the animal, which disease is suffering, etc..
And if the artist is not the master, you will find errors in the harness, anatomy, etc..

Alternatively, find a forum horse breeders/vets, and place the picture of "advice".

By the way, konezavodchiki people are not poor, can...
(?)

[redbor]

[QUOTE="P_Anna;3373311"]redbor, alas, I am already aware of the old examinations..) Because I was surprised that now, for example, in AI the auction is working with the old attribution Silaeva - I also have fotografii@ Nothing amazing. The seller can put the subject as he pleaseth: with expertise or without it, with old or new.
And the buyer has the right to buy or not

[Art-ort]

Сообщение от Гриф

Alas. Now this is why I don't like. Including on this forum. Spices always a shame when "Amateur" sees what they do not see, in spite of years of study and experience.

I again suggest you to contact the experts. See, if you wrote "master", those who work with horses will see many interesting things. The approximate age of the animal, which disease is suffering, etc..
And if the artist is not the master, you will find errors in the harness, anatomy, etc..

Alternatively, find a forum horse breeders/vets, and place the picture of "advice".

By the way, konezavodchiki people are not poor, can...
(?)

I would have been more confused ,that the Plowman size larger than a horse,but this is not a reason to doubt the authorship and go instead of critics to konezavodchiki.

[P_Anna]

Art-ort, tomorrow go, again, to the critic..)
Smiled)

[Гриф]

Сообщение от Art-ort

Me more confused that the Plowman size larger than a horse .

Horses are different. It's not ponies, but ponies (purebred Irish, it seems normal. The feet at the withers. Bred to work in the mines were. There are even such well-established vyrazene: undersized. Yakut, for example...
And the ploughman may be meter so under two.
Gerasim Turgenev, for example, an enviable growth the man was.

PS I looked at the picture, the first thought: illustration and not do it to "Kanaga" C.-Shchedrin?

[P_Anna]

Grif, now I read that he was the Creator of the first Russian art cards and the first Illustrator of the works of F. M. Dostoevsky.