Продам: Maximilian Voloshin

[SergeiSK]

Сообщение от OlgaV

country assessment?

She told me absolutely not seem strange. I can send it to Valery, but did not see the point. This is a genuine examination Silaeva. I have exactly the same when I signed on the back of photos.

[SergeiSK]

In 1998, all could be. Also, it might just be a random signature or the signature of the former owner. I'll send a photo for this examination and if Silaeva Valery answer, then it will write the answer here.

[SergeiSK]

Сообщение от Glasha

I pretty in all respects V. Silaeva now its own stylish forms.

What interesting paper As time will show the same on your sketch Gerasimov

Сообщение от OlgaV

that Peter was a photocopy examination Silaeva

I wrote to Valery, if the answer, make sure you write.
And. We have carefully examined the photos of this Voloshin. Also recognizable watercolor, as well as handwriting Silaeva, but let's say on my examinations on the back is visible brand of photographic paper (Agfa, Fuji), and here a clean sheet. I assume that the photo was taken on normal photographic paper for the printer, but still ... Not ... Like there is no doubt Silaeva handwriting is unique, it is difficult to forge. And I think he is left-handed, I can not tell you.

[spigo]

Glasha, but have you thought that getting this opinion from Valery Stanislavovich, participated in a private transaction with an expert? "I am confident that the publication of this document in a public forum he does not like, and syusi-pusi he does not need .

[Petr]

Dear forum users, I feel we need clarity ..
Again, this does not copy this directly myself examination (plain A4 photocopy of a watercolor Voloshin, signed Silaev ballpoint pen), where it says "examination of GTG." Obtained in visiting days (I think in 1998 it was all one - same Monday) in the department of examination GTG my father.
Two signatures is a signature department employees.

And for you OlgaV, I'm not too lazy and laid out the front of the examination, together with work

[K-Maler]

Сообщение от OlgaV

Do not you tell me that Voloshin wrote one theme, and usually in the same amount. In other words: examination in all cases will be similar or

I noticed that the "under glass" very carefully not only repeats the theme, but color near and far and also drawing plans for the trees ... she is too careful, so to speak.

[SergeiSK]

Petr,
OlgaV,
Quote reply Valeria Silaeva to my letter:
"Thank you Sergey, I do not know how under my signature have been signed by N. Sokolov and LM Tishkovo, this is strange!" These ladies smotrudniki graphics department, which I love and respect, but they are never assured of my expertise and moreover, did not speak to them that someone is treated with this!
But the picture is real and I remember her. And yet, I do not really like the mark of their autographs, even though my sign this, but there are fake! This picture or photocopy?

[Glasha]

spigo, thanks for the warning and apologize Valery Stanislavovich, images removed, all the tweaking
(and not reasonable to write a personal message, for that matter?).
With regards to your "syusi-pusi", "need-not want":
that from the fact that many wanted to say good words about a good man?
And in general, as you know, a kind word and a cat nice ...: p

[Сима]

SergeiSK, well, that you have published a response B. Silaeva, and I wanted to make sure that the names Sokolova and L. Tishkov. The situation with these signatures, apparently, as follows: in 1998 (ie 11 years ago) B. Silaev was not yet such a famous expert, and a restorer at the State Tretyakov Gallery (I hope, and still is). And the ladies mentioned - the keeper of graphics that period. Expertise is usually signed researcher and art and the man who could be responsible for the problems of technological nature. In the case of graphics, does not require special technological research, especially on Mondays, it was a restorer. Ladies do not certify the signature of B. Silaeva Rather, it means that they all looked, and he wrote as a junior. I think.
But I'm really confused, who are here that sells.

[spigo]

Сообщение от Glasha

spigo, thanks for the warning and apologize Valery Stanislavovich, images removed, all the tweaking
(and not reasonable to write a personal message, for that matter?).
With regards to your "syusi-pusi", "need-not want":
that from the fact that many wanted to say good words about a good man?
And in general, as you know, a kind word and a cat nice ...: p

I beg your pardon! Rezkovat.Prosto was little, I realized that in the future, and other participants gathered to publish zaklyucheniya.Ved deal not only with respect to: the collector-expert, it's also the safety of the owners of the paintings and the material for fraudsters, but imalo whether anything else. .