Comparing some of the facts

[khmelev]

Sarabyanova letter is a reply to a similar letter E.N.Petrovoy and Petrov seems to react to the behavior of some of its employees or the Muscovites. But I - alas - I can not find this email Petrova.
  Curiously, who introduced it to the museum Natanova circle? I make out all day its securities , including all sorts of suggestions from Wiesbaden , and I see a monstrous bullshit , just retracted into the trash , but equipped with all possible expertise and opinions.
This is a very complicated history .

[Pavel]

Сообщение от khmelev

Sarabyanova letter is a reply to a similar letter E.N.Petrovoy and Petrov seems to react to the behavior of some of its employees or the Muscovites. But I - alas - I can not find this email Petrova.
  Curiously, who introduced it to the museum Natanova circle? I make out all day its securities , including all sorts of suggestions from Wiesbaden , and I see a monstrous bullshit , just retracted into the trash , but equipped with all possible expertise and opinions.
This is a very complicated history .

Do you want to say good about Plachenov story. If this is the case, then much is clear , and in particular , the ratio of domestic to most artists. CORUPTION ?

[Fed]

Сообщение от Pavel; 2638081 "

CORUPTION ?

It's not corruption , and conspiracy to commit fraud.
Experts , of course, play the fool , it's lightning bug , anyone can make a mistake . And not particularly important - just an opinion expressed by the customer at his request. A customer and not against versa .

 But , in fact - is a conspiracy to defraud gr. money on a large scale . Interestingly, when your police state , this is still not reached.

However, here is a classic version of the scam when deceived unprofitable to go to the police.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Fed; 2638101 "

True, there is a classic version of the scam when deceived unprofitable to go to the police.

If Edward Nathan and sold something from his " collection has ", then only the there, but not in Russia .
He exhibitions in Russia and needed something were to provenance , to put things in their catalogs of exhibitions ..

[Маруся]

Сообщение от khmelev; 2637351"

I have a very modest interest. At the time, Mr. Nathan staged exhibitions in Yaroslavl. http://www.museum.ru/N21373
Output directory.

Here are the appropriate exhibitions and publications related to the "collection" of Mr. Natanova:
"Masters of Russian avant-garde." Exhibition catalog. - Pereslavl. 2002

Masters of Russian avant-garde: Exhibition of works from the collection of the Yaroslavl Art Museum, Pereslavl Art Museum and private collections Edik Natanova (Germany) - Moscow: North. pilgrim, 2003

Yurova LL Russian avant-garde in the collection of the Yaroslavl Art Museum. - Moscow: North pilgrim, 2009.

It should be noted that the editor of the latest edition of A was Yurlova M Valyaeva I suspect that all of the many expert - is also its

And that's masterpieces from the collection of e Natanova (Masters of Russian avant-garde. Pilgrim North. 2003):

Udaltsov NA - Composition with three figures. The second half of the 1910s.
Udaltsov NA - Composition with four figures. The second half of the 1910s.
Udaltsov NA - The Seamstress. The second half of the 1910s.
Chagall MZ - The old man and the village. 1914.
Exter AG - Composition. 1916-1917.
Jawlensky AG - Portrait of a girl. 1913.
Jawlensky AG - Portrait of a young girl in the red. 1913

PS Sorry, the topic turned to the "assessment" may be good administrators will fix "it in the" Kaleidoscope "?

[Евгений]

Сообщение от Maroussia ; 2638361 "

Here's masterpieces from the collection of e Natanova

"Masterpieces " in quotation marks , or take or mail - fraud scam artist from Natanova .

Сообщение от Maroussia ; 2638361"

PS Sorry , the topic turned to the "assessment " may be good administrators will fix " it in the" Kaleidoscope "?

Topic should be moved to where it is supposed to be .. :
" Beware of fake paintings !"
http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showthread.php?t=7665
this shit , along with the "expert " M. Valyaeva only there and place ..

[Маруся]

I'm ashamed to say , I thought that everything is clear without the quotes <! - ~ 1 ~ ->

Eugene, I think the question is not only and not so much about fakes - this has long been nothing new and is not even a conscious or ' irresponsible ' participation in the process of some Russian experts
And that, in the process , including the Russian museum community And not ordinary provincial museums and museums that hold significant collections of Russian avant-garde

[khmelev]

I think that it is better to leave it a separate topic , p.ch. there is not the banal bullshit production and patronage in the process of the titled art , museums, and government officials.
I 'll try to find a typical example of " natanovskih " market place here and to all of the above was obvious

Добавлено через 31 минуту
certainly incorrect to express any thoughts zaglazno, but in the context of an investigation initiated and letters Sarabyanova it is appropriate to look to see how some of the documents

[khmelev]

certainly incorrect to express any thoughts zaglazno, but in the context of an investigation initiated and letters Sarabyanova it is appropriate to look to see how some of the documents

[Fed]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

And who was supposed to "get"?

The prosecutor's office, certainly.


"Exhibition on Tour (" Alexandra Exter and her friends ") are interested in the prosecutor's office, because in this project big money."