And about this thing that someone can say?

[патриот]

Sorry, but Vereshagina weak.

[наследник]

Сообщение от uriart

heir, nothing strange in the signature can not see.
I had a job Vereshagina size 24h18, on the theme "Shipka", "A soldier of the Russian army." The signature was complete - V. Vereshchagin.
And the work has passed all examinations in Moscow, even in the 90-ies.

Work was - oil on canvas?

Regarding these pictures follow the principle - "All doubts are to be interpreted in favor of the accused." If it is proved the obvious.
  And yet proven. It is hoped that not prove - sorry to be disappointed.
Still ... examination was? And where they spent?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от uriart

I had a job Vereshagina size 24h18, on the theme "Shipka", "A soldier of the Russian Army".

Something This model?

[Hobbema]

Thoughts were on sale, but at the price I thought. Considering the proposals. By the way, I did not expert, but I am inclined to think that the picture is genuine, given that it was acquired by an old professor's family many years ago.

[uriart]

Cyril Syzransky, so this exercise and similar to the one that was with me.
And this work does not pull on the plot Vasily Vereshchagin.
Perhaps it is Vasily Petrovich? Although the monitor is not a make out.
Moreover, there is no work for comparison.

[SergeiSK]

Сообщение от uriart

Perhaps it is Vasily Petrovich?

Hardly ... For directories it is characterized as a "serial academics with excellent training." Well, here we see that:

Сообщение от redbor

if a girl dropping her hands, then to the ground,
but to his knees as if she'll get.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от uriart

Perhaps it is Vasily Petrovich? Although the monitor is not a make out.
Moreover, there is no work for comparison.

Yes, it is difficult. But in the State Tretyakov Gallery is B. Petrovich.

Сообщение от uriart

yes this exercise and similar to the one that was with me.

That's what I thought. I think Vereshchagin they did with a couple of dozen for gifts as souvenirs of the Balkan war. There is still the same soldier, but turned in the opposite direction. The idea is not mine, a prominent Moscow, told the judge he made a dozen opinions on these soldiers. All poddlinnye.

[redbor]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

I thought as much. I think Vereshchagin they did with a couple of dozen for gifts as souvenirs of the Balkan war. .

In 1864, what was war?
You seriously want to drag this picture to someone from Vereshchagins?
  I think only Pavel Vereshchagin so he could draw,
while at the office work was not. Yes, and then only with the help Petrukha

[redbor]

Signed "V. Vereshchagin 1864.
Assuming Vereshchagin, want to sell?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Hobbema

Signed "V. Vereshchagin 1864"

If the conversation is about Vasily, the 1864-th year, he number of formal student IAH to 65 th, the fact has left us with her in 63 th and made a trip to the Caucasus "with artistic purpose," and already in 64 nd went to Paris, where he remained until the winter of 66-67 years. while studying at the Academy of Fine Arts in studio J.-L. Jérôme.
And when it comes to Vasily Petrovich, he was 63 to 69 Messrs. retired IAH abroad. After visiting Berlin, Dresden, Vienna, Munich, he settled in Paris, and a 64-second, he lived and worked in Rome.
By the way, presented a picture more suited to him. But the signature ...

[color="# 666686"]Added after 5 minutes[/color]

Сообщение от Hobbema

I am inclined to think that the picture is genuine, given that it was acquired by an old professor's family many years ago.

Nothing is meant.
"Professorial family" could hang on the walls of his house professorkogo anything if he professor is not an art critic, of course, and even then, not a fact. I know that sometimes have art hanging, they laughed: "The shoemaker without shoes, as always ..."
And some of the paintings have already sick, though his eyes rest at home ...