New (art) MMM

[Магнолия]

Konstantin, please answer, and the first part of my question about the "Leonardo da Vinci and Pavel Popov?"
This is important for the perception of information I read, and not only in our forum.

Thank you in advance.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Magnolia, 2423051

is not indifferent to me now, man learns French in high school for arts auctioneer.

?????

He studies at the auctioneer-litsitator - the guiding in the hall or on the auction auctioneer - expert and appraiser?

[Магнолия]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran

or

expert and appraiser

[Konstantin]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran ; 2423121"

or auctioneer - expert and appraiser ?

In France, not very clear why , but it was such requirements to leading trading. Has the right to trade a person with a degree from an expert and appraiser. Probably think that way everything will be honest, as a leading expert will not be vparivat falshaki , but as an appraiser will not increase prices . >

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Magnolia, 2423141

expert and appraiser

Oh!

Then to your question

Сообщение от Magnolia, 2423051

What is more important, art or finance?

I can not answer.

Art history, art criticism, znatochestvo.

[Vladimir]

A bad idea. Informed buyers (or at least properly frightened at specialized seminars on art- investment) to any art- MMM not vvyazhutsya . That is the threat of this will be focused on the least protected , least prepared audience - the meat for any pyramid. It is clear that this is no good end can not.

The real problem, as I understand it , is to pump up the market with money to send transactions and uncertain buyers realize that the market is a kind of life? Well, for that there are quite civilized mechanisms - such as collective investment funds , which have only be afoot . But in general it depends on the investment climate , on which to work. Improve it , by the way , it is the technical problem , all the regulations stated. There is no way that all sectors - stagnation and corruption, as in the art of all rushing.

[artcol]

Сообщение от Vladimir

was a bad idea. Informed buyers (or at least properly frightened at specialized seminars on art-investment) to any art-MMM not vvyazhutsya. That is the threat of this will be focused on the least protected, least prepared audience - the meat for any pyramid. It is clear that this is no good end can not.

The real problem, as I understand it, is to pump up the market with money to send transactions and uncertain buyers realize that the market is a kind of life? Well, for that there are quite civilized mechanisms - such as collective investment funds, which have only be afoot. But in general it depends on the investment climate, on which to work. Improve it, by the way, it is the technical problem, all the regulations stated. There is no way that all sectors - stagnation and corruption, as in the art of all rushing.

What's the idea? I have not announced it yet. Just did pounce the idea - look at the temperature in the hospital, so to speak. So while the findings do not really early, and not even about.

Now to the point. About real problem - I agree. Do not go there money. So we began to utter the magic spell: "collective investment funds - the investment climate - ..." etc. But few spells - need a mechanism. Mavrodi was here at such a mechanism, but a mathematician, not a "charmer texts."

Do not get me wrong - the texts are needed, I read your text, and there are many useful and interesting, but said generally believe only once. Unfortunately, the predictions about the growth of all things did not materialize, investors got burned, and now try to watch from a distance and wait for the "improvement of the investment climate."

Need a simple, transparent mechanism. Type mavrodievskoy pyramid. Not in shape and not on the basis, of course, but as an analogy working.

[Konstantin]

Сообщение от artcol

Need a simple, transparent mechanism.

And all to be rich and healthy at the same time?

Good idea.
Just as an example of why taking Mavrodi?
Oil can be taken as an example, also works and is even better now.

[Магнолия]

I realized that the auctioneer-litsitatora (the guiding trading in the hall) in France do not teach.

[Konstantin]

Сообщение от Magnolia , 2423111"

answer, please, and for the first part of my question

Сообщение от Magnolia , 2423051 "

is not only informative value of paintings, but also ? another , which was assessed in the currency .

Do not quite understand what you need to answer that for the value of pattern is measured by money ?
If you strongly not to go into complex reasoning , the value of the picture , and in this concept as a deficit in the broadest sense. If you want a picture to have a lot of people, you will get it the one who pays the most. Simplistic view ? Well, partly , the other question is why this or that picture suddenly want to own a lot of people. Here list the reasons can be long.