Opinion on the level of art

[Tana]

Cyril Syzransky, uriart, dedulya37 thanks for your comments!
  I do not know how to call it, but it happens sometimes "found", initially enjoyed painting, especially as hrizantemki written, color, brought home, and of course, was to look at (I love to deal with all the minutest details) and it was then, and noticed this "roughness table and sketched parts and as soon as they saw everything, now can only see them (if it would be more understandable sketch )!!!!
Here are unregistered land is somehow understandable, but the "sketch" and a translucent layer, I think it is as though he wrote and crossed out the written picked up as a neakuratno looks for realism ....( of course be at the forefront, impressionism , non-conformism, contemporary art)
In general, rarely doubt like to wait until the dust settles impressions (day 2) and then did not regret the purchase, but here in the evening puzzled, morning woke up and saw only a sketch (on the photo it is less visible) in the gallery, she stood in the little dark spot so that nothing could be seen ...

As for the author's work, he no longer held administrative posts, was the curator of the gallery and taught art and studied briefly, one of them carried portraits is in the National Portrait Gallery in London (now with this picture, I compared the signature, such as too is not quite similar, at my picture is too "spelled out"), just looked at what was sold at auction, the signatures in general are very different, because somewhere in block letters is written, somewhere only printed the initials in the gallery is more like a cursory signature, but I just though the exam on calligraphy go, so every year, and emerged bearing, the same signature on my picture altogether unlike anything one of the seen (the picture was purchased galereey at auction)

So given all this, returned it today, I do not want to keep gnawing worm of doubt. "
Many thanks for your feedback !!!!
Well when in a "difficult" moment is someone close even "virtually" to discuss all doubt.: Shy:

[Sandro]

Сообщение от Tana

So given all this, returned it today, I do not want to keep gnawing worm of doubt ".

That's right! I did not like the picture ...: shy:
Less (by number) but better (quality)!

[Tana]

dedulya37 looked at your sketches from the boat, and - like them, and there is no doubt!
 
in your sketches all the "right" look, a different matter if the sketch was on another boat depicted beside or shape, and then its a sketch artist, but the image is all the same transmission and it seems to me "spoil" the big picture, preventing perceptual, t . k. see what happened before the final version.

agreed that when the "how-to and" yes "and how-to and" no "- probably the best way not to suffer and recover ...
There are so creative meal are not only the artists!! : shy:
Thank you all for your help !!!

[Артём]

Сообщение от Sandro

Less (by number) but better (quality)!

Tana, painstaking work of student, although pleasant. If this is realism, but it is realism, he pulls over a certain amount of dogma by which we assess the quality and realism. Timid possession of material, bad picture! Sorry, that sharp.

[Tana]

Thank you, Artem, that's because I felt that the work unprofessionally executed, as an amateur.

[LCR]

Сообщение от uriart

Tana, often unregistered plots paintings are part of the composition picture itself.

It agrees with you and Grandpa.
Here's another example, it delights me with its daring (generally speaking, is not peculiar Roginsky), look at the car on the left: all white - is just a primer!

[Артём]

Сообщение от LCR

Tana, often unregistered plots paintings are part of the composition picture itself.

I Schaufler even part of the technology - nedopisannost work. This is normal, but within the whole professional experience of the work.

[Самвел]

We Otroshchenko almost all the works of the background is, or soil, or the color of the paper. Everything is white or primer or color paper.

[uriart]

Tana, not lyagla per capita, correctly returned. Works would not be in joy and be constantly irritated. But this should not be!
All works purchased for myself dolzhney be a joy!