? Sarian Please help identify the author

[Alkalan]

Сообщение от Maroussia ; 1954091"

There is an autograph copy of Dmitrii Vladimirovich Sarabianov confirmation of authorship - in my opinion, this is something so mean .

Thanks for the advice . However , the authenticity of the autograph Dmitry Vladimirovich is for me a fact that does not require additional evidence. But agree, in favor of the authorship of Saryan, but the views of the two major authorities ( Schuster, Sarabyanov ) did not indicate . I think that the reasoning in favor of the authorship of Saryan counterproductive.

[khmelev]

Could you post a bigger turnover.
Hard to see but now I can say that the stretcher could not do in RM Schuster

[Игорь Гурьев]

With the same success, and even more, this picture can be attributed to A. Kravchenko, V. Behteevu and even Ulyanov!

[khmelev]

Now take a closer look.
Most likely a fake inscription Shusterovskaya.
Give plenty of inscription.

[Маруся]

Сообщение от Alkalan; 1954321"

However , the authenticity of the autograph Dmitry Vladimirovich is for me a fact that does not require additional evidence. But agree, in favor of the authorship of Saryan, but the views of the two major authorities ( Schuster, Sarabyanov ) did not indicate . I think that the reasoning in favor of the authorship of Saryan counterproductive.

I can only apologize for his proposal ...

But if the " opinion of the two major authorities ( Schuster, Sarabyanov )" You do not have enough , something well, I can only add that "the current authorities" have learned from textbooks , DV Sarabianov and at his lectures at Moscow State University ...

As far as the Sarian, you can read his diaries ( archives) . At one time in great detail describing their work ...

[Игорь Гурьев]

Сообщение от Maroussia ; 1954461"

all "current authority ", at best , learning from textbooks , DV Sarabianov and at his lectures at Moscow State University ...

You are mistaken.
Sarabyanov not taught formal analysis .
He talked about all the ideological significance of this or that or the third , but I believe it has always been known that in the "kitchen" painting was little he flogs .
It never was not disputed .

Formal analysis of other people are taught , for example, Rima Savko .
Now - Alexei Rastorguyev , for example.

[Маруся]

Сообщение от Igor Guryev

Sarabyanov not taught formal analysis.

I always thought that the history of art.
At least, I read these books.

[Игорь Гурьев]

Сообщение от Maroussia

whose opinions, no matter what, will outweigh the "S. Schuster, and DV (not AD) Sarabianov"?

Yes, many whose.


Any artist can ask.

[Маруся]

Yes, exactly, "the artist can offend everyone."

[mihailovoh]

Alkalan,
 
Zaitrigovali.Zachem break kopya.otdayte work on a new examination.
 
Even if Mr. \\ h.rabota is not bad.