Experts in Goncharova, what do you think?

[Toinen]

Not discussed the quality of the painting, and authorship.

[redbor]

Сообщение от John Preston

Well, still no absolute fake, IMHO there are chances that the present.

It is necessary to test a chance.
Pindos just do not understand and did not buy because

Сообщение от Toinen

Leslie Hindman Auctioneers is not Santa Claus.

Well, at least in the Snow Maiden pull?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от redbor

should try a chance.

So I know.
Must have.

[Toinen]

Сообщение от redbor

Well, at least in the Snow Maiden pull?

Outwardly something Transfiguration Tanya recalled.

[OlegTsi]

Сообщение от sem21; 1933471"

here is found one picture of Goncharova at auction, as you think real or not

Sem21, excuse me for being frank. I do not think you have found, as you found it.
Because the auction is Leslie Hindman, Chicago, Il, USA held on 11 December 2011, and the painting was sold for 10 thousand dollars, then start with these words the topic of this film is not appropriate.

This picture is not in the search database, anywhere information about upcoming auctions it does not. Her other day to find it was not possible, except in the auction results database.

But there was plenty of time (from 11 December until the appearance of your message) to deliver this picture from Chicago to the buyer.
Your interest in this picture explain just one thing - you are the "lucky", which bought it at the Chicago auction.

If the trace on the topic, I showed you how to fake this auction broke under Goncharov (minimum 4), which were previously published in the scandalous books and Bazetu Parton.

At the auction frauds are paving the path. And if you cheat and cheaters udaetsya auctioneer and the buyer, the door of the auction for the flow of fakes is opened very wide. Examples - hundreds of them.

Increasingly, scammers describe the all-time stories and add provenance, which is not possible to verify.

Here we have a such a citation:

Сообщение от Igor Guryev; 1933931"

The point is that the picture is not much worse than other recent Goncharov ...

Guriev, Igor, except here we are talking about the late work of art Goncharova? Why this comparison?

That's what was written as an auction Provenance:

Provenance:
Purchased in Paris, 1930's

And where purchased? Close to the artist? - No, this would be discussed. In the gallery? The exhibition and sale? - No, because the picture of PA 1930 were very discreet and always stuck to their details to the picture. And there's nothing there.
Painting technique is also not too similar to the hand Goncharova. By the way, he approved of this respected Guriev, Igor, expressed my opinion about this movie before:

Сообщение от Igor Guryev; 1885511"

have a completely different style Goncharova: awkward, restless.

And the size of the picture is not European. - 69.85 cm x 49.53 cm (27.5 x 19.5 inches)

And not least - leaving the picture at an auction 10 thousand dollars - for the period Goncharov 20-30's, almost the size of 70 to 50 cm !!!!!!

That is, a picture, "kupennaya" in the 30's in PA claims in the category of not so recent works.

Therefore, Sem21, keep up with the news forum, sometimes they save their money helps.

If this picture is owned by Natalia Goncharova and her hand would have been written prior to the 30's, it would look something like the picture number 2 - Natalia Goncharova's painting "Peony."

[Игорь Гурьев]

Сообщение от OlegTsi

If this picture is owned by Natalia Goncharova and her hand would have been written prior to the 30's, it would look something like the picture number 2 - Natalia Goncharova's painting "Peony."

Yes, but these gorgeous peonies - this is the 1910s, EMNIP.

And then she was so did not write, alas.

[OlegTsi]

Сообщение от Igor Guryev

Yes, but these gorgeous peonies - this is the 1910s, EMNIP.

And then she was so did not write, alas.

This is understandable.
But this picture is "purchased" in the 30s.
TE
it was not created nor in the 40's or 50's or 60's.

[Игорь Гурьев]

I do rather like the late Pavel Kuznetsov than Goncharova.


Although rather weak for Pavel Kuznetsov, frankly.

[sem21]

Thank you for all statements .....
But now I do not buy this, it was bought by my friend in America, and bragged to me!
I just wanted to know what the experts think about it !!!!!!

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от sem21

my friend bought it in America, and bragged to me!
I just wanted to know what the experts think about it !!!!!!

Here, the familiar boasted to you, and now everyone knows that your friend bought it.
>