Fakes ... Fakes ...

[OlegTsi]

Auction Kaminski Auctions, 564 Cabot Street, Beverly, MA 01915



Lot 3115


Tarkhoff, Still Life, O /C


Still life with onions, oil on canvas, signed Nikolai Aleksandrovich Tarkhov (Russian, 1871-1930), 14 "x 18".


Estimate $ 6,000 - $ 8,000


Used a picture of the American standard size - 14h18 inches and oversubscribed.

[ANATOLY]

OlegTsi, mean, would put the price of $ 100 and can be someone bought and radovalsya.A even when Burliuk billed at the price of costs it is unlikely that buyers do not realize that pokupayut.Mozhet be on the back the fine print under the magnifying glass 100- fold says " copy" or " ala Burliuk ." Danger that these "masterpieces" are trying to sell at market value.

Added after 21 minutes
OlegTsi, A rather strange when first natyurmort.Vo Tarkhov clearly subscribed , he has always tilt to the left, when more than a casual T signed up as expected, sometimes the top of the T threw a stick on the right , but I have never have not seen such a signature. 2 - he has never had a stroke , he has bigger and moschney.Podlinnost picture is questionable.

Added after 24 minutes
Toinen, Thank you.

[OlegTsi]

Сообщение от ANATOLY; 1981751"

Danger that these "masterpieces" are trying to sell at market value .

It does not agree. I wish that there was no fraud at all in the market. But still , better, let all the fakes assigning twice the price of the market than are sold at artificially low . First, the chance to sell it to zero, and secondly , the index of the market value of the works for a specific author is not ponizhatsya . After all, statistics are kept clean by dataprojektor calculation.

Сообщение от ANATOLY; 1981751"

Pretty strange still life

It would be strange if the hand belonged to Tarkhova .

Сообщение от ANATOLY; 1981751"

pictures of authenticity is in doubt .

No doubt, you should not call the picture . This is clearly a 100%fake.

[ANATOLY]

OlegTsi, you have an expert on Burlyuk, visit sovkoma and see the March auction, lot 158, Burliuk costs only 20,000 dollarov.A YOU we offer the American Burliuks for a knockdown price of 03.02 m
dollars.
There's still four pieces for every taste.

[OlegTsi]

Сообщение от ANATOLY

go to the website and see sovkoma the March auction, lot 158, Burliuk

I asked you to let us link.
Faster and more convenient.
Thank you.



I looked.
Lot 158 ​​- looks normal.

http://sovcom.ru/index.php?category=...58&auction=158

Добавлено через 1 час 42 минуты
In anticipation of another victim:


Auction Kaminski Auctions, 564 Cabot Street, Beverly, MA 01915 perdlagaet:


Lot 3108


Choultse, O /C

Oil on canvas, signed Ivan Fedorovich Choultse (Russian, 1877-1932), 27 "x 39 1/2".


Estimate $ 15,000 - $ 20,000

[OlegTsi]

In anticipation of another victim:


Auction Kaminski Auctions, 564 Cabot Street, Beverly, MA 01915 perdlagaet:


Lot 3108


Choultse, O /C

Oil on canvas, signed Ivan Fedorovich Choultse (Russian, 1877-1932), 27 "x 39 1/2".


Estimate $ 15,000 - $ 20,000

[ANATOLY]

Ladies and Gentlemen! There is no doubt that on this forum a lot of people well versed in the art, but I am concerned over the fact that without seeing the work live, without spending the minimum of research, often conclude that-fake. This work has been exhibited Tarkhova and I am familiar with his work, his manner of writing and signature, and also expressed doubts about this rabote.Ya 70 percent sure that he is not. However, what if we find in life Tarkhova period when he wrote. Therefore there should be a detailed study of a specialist who knows this artist. Oleg Qi in the past year has shown Nude Mashkova.Razve a copy of the Vologda galleries? No. Forgery? Do not be znayu.Mozhet. And if the artist's friends were asked to repeat this work and it is not bothering, but he could not refuse, made another sketch, a signature delivered sloppy, as the graphic itself. There is a contemporary artist Alexei Zaitsev, with his works can be found on the site, ARTRUSSIYA, had I purchased several works, nice little commercial little things. I really liked the painting "The Lessons of Seduction" and asked him to repeat, but this time with my daughters. He did, I declined to 5.6 leading reasons why, he replied that address these shortcomings can not be. This picture is far weighs on the site are not sold. When I started to deal thoroughly with this picture, I learned that he wrote them, and five pieces, each time getting worse and worse. And if he wrote one for myself, as it were, then the following for the needs of the buyer. And the buyers are all different. And after 30 years, my granddaughter would say that the rest of the fakes, and they have the originals. And now and then, many artists are doing repetitive especially successful works, and not always successful. So it probably would be correct if you know for sure that it is a fake then give information, if in doubt then argumentiruesh. And then think themselves "to have or not have."

[OlegTsi]

Dear Anatoly.

Have you ever for a moment, imagine what the Russian artist living in Western Europe, to get American Standard stretcher with the same standard American frame, when these exist, local shops and workshops?
Indeed, in most cases, the U.S. auctions are sold counterfeits of Russian artists made in the old American pictures by unknown artists, peremytyh, copied and oversubscribed. Buy antique shop or flea market finds a suitable raw material, fraudsters can easily destroy the old picture and create something new in it for the subsequent fraud.
Note that the fraud involved artists painting subjects. In some cases, this is amateur, other professionals, a career which has failed as an independent maestro.

Сообщение от ANATOLY; 1983781"

Oleg Qi in the past year has shown Nude Mashkova.Razve a copy of the Vologda galleries? No. Forgery? Do not be znayu.Mozhet

I already asked you to insert a link will be immediately evident what it is. So let's see and discuss Mashkov.

Hmm, again Mashkov again, Anatoly ... <! - ~ 9 ~ ->

[ANATOLY]

Сообщение от OlegTsi

glaring new find in the works of Ilya Ivanovich Mashkov !
New works Mashkov might envy not one museum. It must have been a masterpiece of this Attributed Boston private callprojection was proud owners. At the moment, is saturated with such pride auction Trinity International Auctions and his team . <! - ~ 7 ~ ->

Lot 107


ILYA IVANOVICH MASHKOV (ATTR) RUSSIAN 1881-1944 "Sitting Nude Composition" Mixed media on artist board 11 1/2 x 6 3/4 in (29.2 x 17.1 cm) signed lower left From a private collector, Boston, MA

Maybe Mashkov ?

[Valerit]

Сообщение от John Preston

But such obvious zalipuhi as the St Petersburg String March auction "Gelos" I do not see ever ...


Signature not Kaigorodov, and Kaydogodoff <! - ~ 7 ~ ->

And the work properly and signature look.

Part of his legacy remains in Tallinn.
There are pictures.