Vekselberg has accused Christie's in counterfeit trade

[Кирилл Сызранский]

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Konstantin

Tjutchev move the conversation in a calm tone and you will be responsible, why do all the time ripping his shirt on his chest. You a little example that tolkol that resulted?
Fritz Carl Werner EBEL (1835-1895)

EBEL arisen in a Shishkin. I'm waiting for examples in connection with Bogolyubov. I do not have spray every stupidity uttered in this forum.

Which to me claim? I do not understand? People have written, I answered. What is the problem?

I do not blame that on this forum is full of amateurs, do not respect the rules of fair debate. Why say something that you can not prove. It's called chatter! And if there is such a word as "gossip", and it is not obscene, then why can not pronounce? And tell me how to call such people! Great connoisseurs of art, perhaps?

[Игорь Гурьев]

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Vladimir

Colleagues, let's finish with Boogolyubovym. The disposition is clear - no one 50 works is not going to call. The rest of recriminations are not interesting. Interest about Kustodiev, Vekselberg and Christie

All posts that mention the name of the Bogolyubov move into my topic about this artist. I do not mind.

My theme of Bogoliubovo

[Кирилл Сызранский]

[Игорь Гурьев]

[Тютчев]

[OlegTsi]

Сообщение от Guriev, Igor

How to record" Mashkov "at the same Sotheby's

I am very interested to know more work Mashkov. This is a work sold in London in 2005 for more than 2 million pounds? Please share. If it is convenient - a different topic, including Fakes ... Fakes ... Thank you.

[Игорь Гурьев]

Сообщение от Tjutchev

Contemporaries Alexei Petrovich Bogolyubov who wrote Sea (academic orientation).

First, we need to agree on criteria.

How do you think is better Svedomsky Bouguereau?

Added after 2 minutes

Сообщение от OlegTsi

I am very interested to hear more work Mashkov. This is a work sold in London in 2005 for more than 2 million pounds? Please share. If it is convenient - in another topic, including Fakes ... Fakes ...

It is also appropriate.
Because it is close to Kustodiev case - at least in the time frame.
I do not know who bought that "Mashkova", but I know that this is not Mashkov.
And not only me but also the various friends who have a second opinion, many times checked for other jobs, etc.

You see, Mashkov never in Counteropenwork manner not write.
That is, for a start.
Painting, I repeat, is created somewhere in the first quarter of the 20 th century, probably in Belgium, some local enough skilled artist.

Boring composition (such as disorderly soldiers on the parade ground), a poisonous yellow (where are you saw a Mashkova? Mashkov always warm, but not poisonous) awry left pot (Ilya Ivanovich actually knew how to paint), etc.

This is absolutely "botanical" Still Life, of which Mashkov nobody ever wrote.
"Botanical" picture writing, say, Stanislav Yulianovich Zhukovsky (flowers on the window, shoots, remember?), But not Mashkov.

Mashkov, if anything, have created a model of the cosmos in his still lifes, but not botanical studies.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от OlegTsi

This is a work sold in London in 2005 for more than 2 million pounds?

Yes, about this still life. Sold 01/12/2005 for (if talking about the dollar) 3,695,921 USD (2,136,000 GBP) with a very modest estimeyt 200 000 - 300 000 GBP.

Igor Guriev, in the auction description there is mention that this still life exhibited in Amsterdam in 1913 in the Stedelijk Museum, E.