"Black Square" by Malevich: who feels that, looking at this picture

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от artist

not "torknulo "))))

And, it ...
Well, well ...
I, for one, long look at the Crimean Cheka can not: "torkoet" really is not very childish, and just "stomps" and "sausage" ...

[Маруся]

Сообщение от artist

Still, the greatness of the author provides for his professionalism (this is not a sufficient condition, of course, but necessary). Many laymen to buy and sell in the past century, and did not give any "Great". Price High was given, and the Great - no.

Dear Artist,
In connection with your "opinion" question of professionalism:
Professional artist - who is this? Who earns a living, or even if you can not make money - still lives her profession? Or someone who has a degree of professional school?
I hope you know that none of the first names of Russian avant-garde never finished either AX or MUZHVZ: some - were driven out, someone would go himself because of academic boredom, not to mention the "amateur", which are both nowhere and not adopted and those who never go there and did not treat ...
How can that be? Remove the epithet "great" and leave "expensive sold?
And, for example, Van Gogh? Or is it too you is "impression": that "what is he ..." not a professional?

[uriart]

Maroussia, That's Van Gogh, me personally, very impressive.
And the KGB did well!
Do you want and I'll draw this?

[Маруся]

Сообщение от uriart

Do you want and I'll draw this?

Yuri! Of course I want!
You know how warmly I am to you, so your version will accept with pleasure!
But, believe me, to draw a "black box" must be Malevich, Malevich and if not, then we ought to be first, ie The first who theoretically reduced art to simple geometric forms and the whole color spectrum expressed in two: the color and no color.

[uriart]

Maroussia, I do not accept this and agree with the version li Glazunov.
And to Malevich and after was a lot of artists who have left us a tremendous musical legacy.
On the work of Malevich, Popova, and others like them look like expensive pictures.
You'd forgive me gray, I zdaetsya that the merit Malevich was only in the fact that he first drew it and fuss in the world.
And made to attract the attention of their novelty geometric patterns.
And off they'd go ... a genius, etc.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от uriart

... he first drew it and fuss all over the world.

Well, say that Malevich "fuss for the whole world"-bust.
Here let us remember, when we have the opportunity to see the Cheka.
Here you are yourself remember?

[Маруся]

What then, sir, with this attitude draw I did not want ...
But your "gone go ... genius" got me thinking: Is not the genius of the man who invented the wheel? For the same ride on it (even four), and do not think, who say thank you.
The same geniuses Malevich and Kandinsky - they "invented" the wheel of abstraction ", which for nearly a century ride many artists.
But in contrast to an unknown Greek, they do know who should be grateful, at least in the Western art scholarship this question can not be doubted: it opens a new direction in art. Like it or not. Cancel you it can not, as well as cancel the wheel.

Added after 13 minutes

Сообщение от Cyril Syzranskiy

Quote:
Message from uriart View Post
... He first drew it and fuss for the whole world.
Well, say that Malevich "fuss for the whole world"-bust.
Here let us remember, when we have the opportunity to see the Cheka.
Here you are yourself remember?

COP kindly requested with quotes (especially the sales results with AI), "poddakivaniem" and "podnekivaniem" abstain. You're a famous person on the forum, that would have written a full, reasoned post and expressed to his opinion. And then somehow not respectable ...

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Maroussia

... in the western art studying this question can not be doubted: it opens a new direction in art.

Why do I need to share art history at the "Western" and "east"? Ultimately, there is simply art history in understanding the European scientific tradition (although I do not think art studies science (in the strict sense of the word)), and Russia is undoubtedly a European country in scientific development (Russian science is a significant part of the European scientific tradition). Russian scientific school without exaggeration one of the most powerful and fruitful.
  
 In Russia, too, were people who knew tsenivshie and avant-garde. Otherwise, how would he survived? Recall, Khardzhiev ...

In general, I Marusia agrees ...

[LCR]

Сообщение от Maroussia

Is not the genius of the man who invented the wheel? For the same ride on it (even four), and do not think, who say thank you.
The same geniuses Malevich and Kandinsky - they "invented" the wheel of abstraction ", which for nearly a century ride many artists.

Remarkably said, bravo, daughter!

[tchaika]

Сообщение от Maroussia

Malevich and Kandinsky - they" invented "the wheel of abstraction", which for nearly a century ride many artists.

Speculators drive from the art and, especially, critics.

Added after 12 minutes

Сообщение от Samvel

Square of Malevich, the event in the art, comparable to same-sex marriage

Good comparison. Same-sex marriages - are sterile. The same futile "Black Square".