Should we discuss the correctness of the rating of Russian artists in the real art of the site?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от ANATOLY; 1955821"

And the prices , well, wanted to please a loved one gentleman /boy with a pipe /, and the price works for him, that for some a pack of cigarettes , for many people on this feed .

Here's another egregious case :
Cezanne for $ 250mln .

 King of Qatar bought for $ 250mln work of Cezanne , " Card Players ". Earlier this painting owned by a Greek tycoon Embirikos . Gagosian offered $ 220mln , but the royal family of Qatar, do not hesitate to pay $ 30 million more, plus a $ 50 million to the mediator.
Never in the world, no one piece of art is not worth $ 300,000,000 . Even the insurance does not exceed $ 200 million .
 

[artist]

Cezanne did not Rothko , no doubt . But the whole world market ( vsego! ) overheated , of course . Where and how - specifically. But the whole is overheated .
And think about it now is not the most illiberal people in the West . That's come up with so far, nothing has happened. But it will come up . This is HUGE and is a real problem . It's called : MODEL DEVELOPMENT.

[Pavel]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran

Here's another egregious case :

O tempora, a mores! ( a )

Slightly changed the rating is now the first to be Cezanne in the world table of ranks and ratings. This shows that there are no permanent ratings that the ratings depend on the sales price , the cost of the quality of painting and the artist's achievement more accurately. Price also depends on inflation , and so I wonder how much it will cost you a sheet when they decide to sell it. Owners are to be congratulated , they defended their money.

[DimaB]

Сообщение от Konstantin

We have just - all born in Russia , you get a rating .:

Kostya , I just realized what a catch ))) Take Carlo Bartolomeo Rastrelli - the sculptor, or even better - his son Bartolomeo Francesco, the great Russian architect. The latter arrived in St. Petersburg at the age of 17 years , and the first - and even earlier . But both unmistakable characters from the history of Russian art. Do not you include them in our auktsionniki if maybe you are lucky to meet them work? This is me - to the convention " registry of birth" . Sorry - but where you are " formed ", " emerged " - there homeland.

[Art-Galera]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran

To solve this dispute once and for all?
But it can not be resolved and why it's necessary?

Cyril! I, basically, and even agree with you. I'm quiet, peaceful dispute with DimaB periodically for a long time ... and all the same and we are left to his own opinion ...
Here's a bit inspired me to discuss the feasibility of such an event that different media - and in fact there is not just sitting pros who somehow can justify their position ... and even the professionals are different opinions ... but those who annually mold some ratings, refer to them, etc., etc. and from what, in principle, they still push off, if everyone in your opinion?

Posted 3 minutes

Сообщение от DimaB

You know, Cyril, each media makes up the ratings on its own. Not the fact that there are sitting real professional. Imagine if we all
got together and decided that our DouDzhons will look exactly )))

That's it. formulated a business as usual - clearly. that really there to talk. and maybe also to highlight the theme here in the most contentious issues and family ... and clearly, you know how? Well, of course, if the theme will be supported.