Sketch help attributing

[OlegTsi]

Santa, in that bygone era, when there were violent confrontations and clashes with the art of Classical art, advanced, revolutionary, among the artists was a struggle for vyzhyvanie. Nobody thought about that in 50-70 years, their works will be of great value. And what kind of value and material interests could be asserted when the whole country has experienced tremendous revolutionary changes with respect to the concepts of commodity-money-commodity.
And why artists today do not create the avant-garde? Yes, because that era is very different. None of those emotions, feelings, changes, experiments, breaking in the directions in art. Today, the artist must think more about the material, because the time is.
Most of the artists who worked after the revolution and the Soviet Union in the early years were filled with emotions sotspepremen, new directions in life and art, so that they all depicted on the posters agitpropagande for theatrical sketches and sketches have been steeped in the spirit of avant-garde, change and innovation, unwillingness repeat the conservative old, and all produced through the prism of worldview artists that was so urgent in those swirling times.

 

Сообщение от Santa; 1624891"

private-poster artist (of which there were many), for standard, routine sketch to a standard poster, must feel the emotions you mentioned?

If an artist does not feel emotions during the creation of his work, sketches, sketch, sketch, it's not an artist.
It is in fact is the difference between the artist and those who make it up or trying to fake something for someone.

[Santa]

Сообщение от OlegTsi

Santa
Most of the artists

But there was also a minority , would agree .
I do not say about the artists , with a capital X ( a bit vulgar turned <!--~ 9 " - " but none the less) ..
I'm talking about ordinary artisans , who were a minority (your ratio.)
Maybe you are looking at these sketches of the usual and ordinary , through the prism of the big names at that time .
However , it is difficult to compare Lissitzky and Moore with club poster ( Ivanov , Petrov, ..) . Different objectives , different scales ..
Even geniuses can not be all ( and should not) .
While all are entitled to respect .

[Игорь Гурьев]

In this paper, first of all do not understand the plot .
This could pass for a porter bricks .
But .
Porters bricks wore them on his back on a special stretcher .

Who is it? Mason , carrying a pile of stones ( try it, by the way , I 'll see how it goes ! ) and hammer into the bargain ?

Or is this having such a shirt Supremacist ?
But then, where the figure and the second hand , for example ?

We do not have the artistic and Plastic Logic .
About everyday logic , I have already said .

[Toinen]

Сообщение от "luka77

Design Stencil 20-30-ies

Somehow not convincingly.

[luka77]

Сообщение от OlegTsi

luka77, there under the right leg covered with some letters (signed ).

OlegTsi, the work is not seen only in photos , but the owner insisted that the signature and other inscriptions no .

Сообщение от OlegTsi

Actually , that's reminiscent of such works are exhibited at Ibey seller Korshun c Kiev . There he has a lot of the avant-garde .

Thank you very much , look at Ibey , but feel to establish the authorship will be extremely difficult .

Сообщение от Toinen

What is not convincing .

there are suggestions ?

[Allena]

Сообщение от luka77

the owner insists that the signatures and other inscriptions no.

But under his foot is really something there >

[Toinen]

Сообщение от "Allena

But under the foot is really something there

Trace of the tread sole.

[Konstantin]

Сообщение от Toinen

Next to tread soles.

Yes, it seems.

[I-V]

Striding figure was very fond of Vladimir Lebedev . Of course , this is no reason to talk about his authorship .

Nevertheless , I agree with Santa - an interesting figure . I , as opposed to those that showed the Oleg Tsi, he is remembered . However , like most , herself a figure than then , as it is drawn . So can remember , for example , a good logo , even if it plays the child . So watercolor , this may simply copy the unknown things of a good writer ?

[Игорь Гурьев]

Сообщение от luka77; 1624711 "

watercolor is so hardened that blurs together with the paper ...

"Well, I've never heard about " hardening watercolors .

Has anyone been aware of that phenomenon ?

Maybe you do not do watercolor ?

In general, the same work quite amateur , friable , inept , and personally I have no confidence that this 20- 30- ies .

But even if they are , then the red price it $ 1000.