Auction MagnumArs 22 May 2013.

[Alexgin]

Ask experts to comment on the preliminary price of lots 6 and 8 of the auction (F. and Byalynitsky-Birulya), as well as the level of these works, for any comments thanks in advance.

[Игорь Гурьев]

Well, what about Byalynitsky-Biruli personally I have no doubt in principle no way.
In general, the auction house experts usually gives good thing if in doubt.

About Fedorovich ...
Paintings like the old, and the expertise of Comrade Petrov.



In general, briefly reviewing the entire directory, only one picture was surprised, or rather two.
Number 63. Bookbinders. "Thaw".
Painting - like a modern forger did not even try.
On a typical Perepletchikova (and, in my opinion, the whole Bookbinders - always typical) generally does not like you.
In addition, there are depicted not thawed (this is what happens in the snow) and snow bald spots, I'd say.

Well, number 67. Turzhansky Leonard V. (1875-1945)
Summer landscape with a white horse.
One horse vraskoryaku written, awkwardly at all.
While it is the case with him.
You've got to see in nature, but as they say, the precipitate is: When the whole crown of the tree missed one color when there is absolutely no shades of green meadow (It is usually added more and ocher and orange hues, and then - once the plane) .
But, I repeat, we must see the original, he visited, in general, similar mistakes ...

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Alexgin

comment on the preliminary price of lots 6 and 8 of the auction

Were you surprised by low estimeyty these lots?

Добавлено через 1 час 31 минуту
In the description of the lot Fedorovich

Читать дальше... 

6. Vladimir Fedorovich (1871-1928)
GIRL IN THE BOAT. 1910 - early 1920
Oil on cardboard. 26.8 x 33.7
Signed lower right: Vl. Fedorovich
PUBLICATIONS
Famous old playing card with a very
close in composition of V.N.Fedorovicha,
dated 1922 year.
Painter. Landscape painter. He studied at the Odessa Drawing
School, then at the IAH (1894-1900) and at AIKuindzhi
Kiselev. The picture on the title of the artist was
acquired by the Museum of Arts. Since 1900 - a permanent exhibitor
Exhibition of Arts, TPHV, MOLH a member and exhibitor:
The Company's behalf AIKuindzhi (1917, 1918, 1926-1928)
Petrograd Society of Artists (1918), AHRR
(1926), participated in exhibitions in Rome. Finished painting for
Saratov Cathedral, created the scenery for productions
Mariinsky Theatre. His works are kept in the museum
Academy of Arts in St. Petersburg, Krasnodar, Odessa,
Taganrog and Saratov museums.
Examination VA Petrov
Price forecast 2500 - 3500 $

drew attention to the phrase:

famous old playing card with a very
close in composition of V.N.Fedorovicha,
dated 1922 year.

Is not this card?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

In the description of the lot Fedorovich

Читать дальше... 

6. Vladimir Fedorovich (1871-1928)
GIRL IN THE BOAT. 1910 - early 1920
Oil on cardboard. 26.8 x 33.7
Signed lower right: Vl. Fedorovich
PUBLICATIONS
Famous old playing card with a very
close in composition of V.N.Fedorovicha,
dated 1922 year.
Painter. Landscape painter. He studied at the Odessa Drawing
School, then at the IAH (1894-1900) and at AIKuindzhi
Kiselev. The picture on the title of the artist was
acquired by the Museum of Arts. Since 1900 - a permanent exhibitor
Exhibition of Arts, TPHV, MOLH a member and exhibitor:
The Company's behalf AIKuindzhi (1917, 1918, 1926-1928)
Petrograd Society of Artists (1918), AHRR
(1926), participated in exhibitions in Rome. Finished painting for
Saratov Cathedral, created the scenery for productions
Mariinsky Theatre. His works are kept in the museum
Academy of Arts in St. Petersburg, Krasnodar, Odessa,
Taganrog and Saratov museums.
Examination VA Petrov
Price forecast 2500 - 3500 $

drew attention to the phrase:

famous old playing card with a very
close in composition of V.N.Fedorovicha,
dated 1922 year.

Is not this card?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Speaking of Fedorovich . Everywhere in the literature I see the date of death of the artist - in 1928 . But here in the Four Corners probably know something more.
 Pay attention to the date of death and the date of creation of the work .

[FONT="Arial Number 30 [/URL]
Vladimir Fedorovich (1871 - 1937)
" On the banks of the Dnieper ," 1934
oil on canvas on cardboard, oil , 50.5 X41 (oval) ;
Lower Left " Ow. Fedorovich. In 1934 . "
Vladimir Fedorovich (1871 - 1937)

16,500 - 23,000 $ [/COLOR][/FONT]

[Дилетант]

Yes, they write that in 1928 , the artist does not even dead, but alive and well in the left Smolensk . A website Smolensk Orthodox cemetery in St. Petersburg is listed grave artist V. Yanukovych (1871 - 1937 ).
Anything is possible . Timme - unit age of five graduate courses Bestuzhevskie , in "The Artist Salon Russian " as the work of the artist Riznichenko Ivan G. (?) Published pictures of Riznichenko Litke , etc., etc.
How much more is waiting for its mysteries turandotkinyh Calaf ! <! - ~ 1 ~ ->

[Alexgin]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

you surprised low estimeyty these lots ?
I agree, you can be surprised , especially by comparing lots 8 and 24 :

No , the difference in prices between lots 8 and 24 does not bother me , I'm interested in evaluation of specific work , so to speak , with an average level of the artist . Unless specifically , it (Lot 8) quite bad ?

[Alexgin]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

In the description of the lot Fedorovich

drew attention to the phrase:


Is not this card?

Still a pretty picture.
<! - ~ 1 ~ ->

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Alexgin; 2584181 "

Lots 6 and 8 of the auction ( F. and Byalynitsky - Birulya ),

F. (lot 6) left for 2000 USD, and Byalynitsky - Birulya (Lot 8) - 3700 USD.

A " boy from Cairo " Polenova - the main top lot of the auction (Lot 42), which was a lot prior to bidding went for 205 tons of dollars.

[Konstantin]

Here's our report from the tender:

[QUOTE] In the "Magnum" did not say "bargain", they say "play".
So let's start with the start of the protocol.