I. E. Krachkovsky

[P_Anna]

redbor, hard to say..; yet I think that one and the same. On my picture time more, the sun is low, because the "object" may look higher, darker and more powerful. Wait conclusions and art critic.
Thanks for the feedback!!

[U_Z]

Сообщение от P_Anna

Allena, surrendered today!
Took unconditionally; after a short conversation, during which I dumped all of their arguments, and they have accumulated a lot, took upon confirmation avtorskimi@. That's the story.
And stunning research period))

Kindly met Art consulting)
"Farm on the Dnieper. Fisherman's Wharf"1885
"The boat ashore" 1887

Сообщение от P_Anna

yourself on fire-joined..- I dreamed literally - to not considered crazy)
Don't know what the outcome of all but the last two weeks have been very curious for sure!!

P_Anna, I'm afraid that You have taken excessive perseverance and "persuaded" the organization (for our money, what a pity) to take the work for examination. The author of Your work not s.d.kryzhitskiy/Krachkovsky, IMHO. This can be seen without examination, unless of course, it is not fully recorded.

PS: I'm Afraid that the plate when done. Do, if possible, clear, large photo of the nameplate.

PPS: Very interested in the opinion of experts of the organization, intrigued.

[U_Z]

Сообщение от redbor

There are two heap on the rear, Kryzhitsky there are none.

It houses so shown.

[redbor]

Yeah, razglyadel now: this is the roof of the hut
And sorry, I already thought that there Cheops something built

But before Kryzhitsky, still far

[P_Anna]

U_Z, I thought there anyone not to be persuaded) Sat 4 work, "Krachkovsky-Kryzhitsky" looked for a very long time)
And for your information I shared with them at the time of conclusion of the contract, here.)

The label was on a modern frame in which the work came into the house)

As You view the sky at my picture and on the well-known work Kryzhitsky?)
Similarities, however, there. And in colour, and in causing the stroke.
Waiting for result)

Добавлено через 1 минуту
redbor, I thought You meant the terrain in the background))

[P_Anna]

The result of technological expertise..)
General conclusion:
The combination of materials used in the painting indicates that the picture painted in the end XIX-beginning of XX century.
Signature executed later.

Art is not conducted..

Someone when life Kryzhitsky and Krachkovsky wrote something to the same place, where he loved to "work" s.d.kryzhitskiy..? Or did a similar job? And later someone else had forged the bad, and ...to pay tribute, calligraphic signature, Krachkovsky?
Nonsense.

[P_Anna]

I'll look for expert(s) on creativity Kryzhitsky.. its etudes. For...almost convinced that this is it.
Other versions can't find..(
It is a pity that to come to Ukraine now almost not possible, and if the roots are there, they are there..(

[redbor]

Сообщение от P_Anna

And later someone else had forged the bad, and ...to pay tribute, calligraphic signature, Krachkovsky?

Why was faked? Possibly himself Krachkovsky and signed. Often the authors put a signature after some time. Draws a sketch for themselves, and then there is a need to sell or give away, here and sign

Generally obscure phrase in the act: "the signature is executed later".
What is the "later"? The next day, next month, or next year or after 100 years?

[P_Anna]

redbor, it does not work Krachkovsky's for sure!
There is no option similar signatures, as well as Kryzhitsky..
I tend to the version that this etude last..

Nuuuu not liked the song, and in my version it is weak, changed, and wrote a work with the boat, still living in Chelyabinsk Museum.
Etude left, and a little later, who picked him to play.

I am also perplexed(already at home), the impossibility of even a rough estimate of the time "drawing" signature..
Answers will get after the holidays)

[redbor]

Сообщение от P_Anna

Kryzhitsky..
I tend to the version that this etude last..
Nuuuu not liked the song, and in my version it is weak, changed, and wrote a work with the boat, still living in Chelyabinsk Museum.

Dear P_Anna, in no way want you to agoracart, but even I can see that "your" picture, the one with the boat - are two big differences
These works are written by one person couldn't be
In Chelyabinsk Museum already wrote?