Makovsky, or not?

[Артём]

Сообщение от AlexanderG

Komu-to bantik nravitsia.

Maybe like someone, I will not argue.
Imenno takoi neprofessional'nyi podhod, mozet imet 'razlichnye negativnye posledstviia. Pri otsenke i attributsii nuzen sistematicheskii podhod. Dannaia forma ne informativna i vredna.
Professional portrait, painted by Sfumato. Ie imposed in a manner Sfumato, colors as it were, dissolved in each other, not forming distinct boundaries and effecting haze. Increased tone may occur only at the touch of parts or objects.
In this portrait can be seen as mildly (tonally) fits pillow in the background and the colors are not disrupted by the method. The head girl is the center of the color and tonal composition, the eye almost in the center of the oval, but slightly shifted, which again points to the professional approach of the author. Just the eyes are the darkest spots on the picture and they are the basis of the dynamics and the illusion of life (the imaginary reality).
Bow - regardless of the method. Dramatically inscribed with the moment of fixing the image. In other words, like "nailed" to the head.
Perhaps pririsoval by the author himself after, at the request of the customer.

[AlexanderG]

Сообщение от Artem

Bow - regardless of the method. Dramatically inscribed with the moment of fixing the image. In other words, like "nailed" to the head.
Perhaps pririsoval by the author himself after, at the request of the customer.

Artiom, bantik eto tol'ko odin moment v otsenke dannoi kartiny. V otsenke dannoi kartiny net logicheskoi posledovatel'nosti iznachal'no. I imenno ob etom ia pisal.

[Артём]

Сообщение от AlexanderG

V otsenke dannoi kartiny net logicheskoi posledovatel'nosti iznachal'no.

Agree.
Can add that Makovsky enjoyed the usual three-stage method of painting, nor as not Sfumato. Although everything is relative, can one portrait and wrote, we need deeper examination. To cite one example, the portrait and signature Makovsky, compare.

[redbor]

Сообщение от Artem

need a deeper examination

Really not go without it!

[яков]

Сообщение от Artem

One could add that Makovsky enjoyed the usual three-stage method of painting, nor as not Sfumato.

I can of course be wrong, but look at the photos in post number 12. It seems that now, how it rubbed khim. means, over the years, it has a whitish hue - from the one and Sfumato napominaet.Ne could the author first insert a picture in a frame, and then build upon that either.

[Артём]

Сообщение от "yaks, 839,961

. I could not by first insert a picture in a frame, and then build upon that either.

That is exactly what did the wizard (very often). First, preparing the work podmalevyvali and registration done in the frame. No wonder.