I.E.Krachkovsky (?), "Before the Storm" - Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство

Sergey_YB · 12-02-2013, 16:27

Dear art lovers!

Please help me, whether it is the author's repeated pattern of IE
Krachkovsky "Before the Storm."

1890 Oil on canvas, size 47 x 60 cm, sign more difficult to read, there is damage to the paint layer, covered with varnish.

Кирилл Сызранский · 12-02-2013, 16:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sergey_YB

Please help me, whether it is the author's repeated pattern of IE
Krachkovsky "Before the storm".

Compare yourself with the original.

Quote:

Before the storm.
At the end of the summer,

1888,

Oil on canvas.,

138 x 210,

Odessa Art Museum.

Sergey_YB · 12-02-2013, 17:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cyril Syzran

compare themselves with the original.

Thank you!
Compare.
But I am interested in your opinion as a professional ...
With great gratitude to heed ...

Кирилл Сызранский · 12-02-2013, 17:48

Sergey_YB, as for me, your picture is just a copy of a painting by I. Krachkovsky.

Sergey_YB · 12-02-2013, 18:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cyril Syzran

Sergey_YB, as for me, your picture is just a copy of a painting by I. Krachkovsky.

Maybe so.
But if you do not mind, could you tell the detail, the quality of art (paintings).
Thanks in advance for your reply.

Кирилл Сызранский · 12-02-2013, 18:24

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sergey_YB

But if you do not mind, could you tell the detail, the quality of art (paintings).

And what can I say something?

Amateur copy of a quality I do not see it.

Sergey_YB · 12-02-2013, 21:09

After your comments, there are more questions:
Correct to compare the picture from the Odessa Museum and reduced to 10 times the area of a copy , as it is clearly reflected in the quality of parts picture?

If the author is still IE Krachkovskii then we expect the same quality of the canvas in the lower 10 ? ... the more canvas 120 years without restoration?

Кирилл Сызранский · 12-02-2013, 21:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sergey_YB

correct to compare the picture from the Odessa Museum and reduced to 10 times the area of a copy

Correctly.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sergey_YB

If the author still IE
Krachkovskii then we expect the same quality of the canvas in the lower 10? ...

It is.

Added after 12 minutes

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sergey_YB

correct to compare the picture from the Odessa Museum and reduced to 10 times the area of a copy

Correctly.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sergey_YB

If the author still IE
Krachkovskii then we expect the same quality of the canvas in the lower 10? ...

It is.

Игорь Гурьев · 13-02-2013, 02:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sergey_YB; 2462321"

is this picture of the author's repeated IE Krachkovsky " Before the Storm ."
1890 Oil on canvas, size 47 * 60 cm ,

This is not Krachkovskii no , of course.
And not even the academics .
And by the way , is written quite well.
If I had to hang on a wall or a reproduction of Krachkovsky your things - I would just prefer yours.
Not because it is better written , but because it is written in a different way , not in an academic manner.
Perhaps this is some student later dabbled courses .
And it is possible that later he became quite famous artist.

So indulge artists sometimes - doing freestyle copy famous paintings in his manner .
Recall the "Portrait of Balthazar Castiglione " by Raphael, Rubens freely copied and stored in London ( EMNIP at the Courtauld Institute ).

Дилетант · 13-02-2013, 10:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by Igor Guryev, 2463041

Recall "Portrait of Balthazar Castiglione" by Raphael, Rubens copied freely

As one old friend of mine: "The worst is not when you do not know, and even forget."

>

12-02-2013, 16:27	Original language: Russian #1
Sergey_YB Guest Posts: n/a	I.E.Krachkovsky (?), "Before the Storm" Dear art lovers! Please help me, whether it is the author's repeated pattern of IE Krachkovsky "Before the Storm." 1890 Oil on canvas, size 47 x 60 cm, sign more difficult to read, there is damage to the paint layer, covered with varnish. Attached Thumbnails

12-02-2013, 21:09	Original language: Russian #7
Sergey_YB Guest Posts: n/a	I. E Krachkovskii "Before the Storm" After your comments, there are more questions: Correct to compare the picture from the Odessa Museum and reduced to 10 times the area of a copy , as it is clearly reflected in the quality of parts picture? If the author is still IE Krachkovskii then we expect the same quality of the canvas in the lower 10 ? ... the more canvas 120 years without restoration?

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Sold: 2 paintings members "TPHV", "Company A.I.Kuinzhi", "Community of Artists."	Михалыч	Sell	31	13-02-2014 02:11
Sell: Paul Tiber, "Before the Storm"	chad	Sell	1	11-09-2011 18:04
Krachkovskii, watercolor	BREST	Costs, valuation, attribution	13	06-04-2010 19:17
Sell: Albrecht Adam "Napoleon before the burning of Smolensk"	ранжер	Sell	5	26-08-2009 18:06
Sell: Painting D. Nalbandian "Before the Rain"	SergeiSK	Sell	5	28-07-2009 10:38

12-02-2013, 17:48	Original language: Russian #4
Кирилл Сызранский Гуру Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: РФ, Самара Posts: 75,439 Thanks: 27,871 Thanked 55,339 Times in 24,289 Posts Blog Entries: 126 Reputation: 102399	Sergey_YB, as for me, your picture is just a copy of a painting by I. Krachkovsky.