Interesting up with world famous artists. - Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство

Stuart · 25.10.2011, 22:01

Good day to all ! Maybe I'm just a little is not the topic ...

Stocks stumbled into some interesting copies of the known world masters in the first place I would like to hear the opinion of experts as the quality of copies, perhaps to some estimates, the share of criticism is certainly not without it.

The copy number 1:
Siemiradzki Ippolitovich Henry (1843-1902)
Polish and Russian artist, one of the largest representatives of the Russian academic art.

Canvas - Oil, a copy was made in 1939.

Fragments of a little blurred (shooting without a tripod ) , but in general shows the level of performance .

Copy number 2:
David Alfaro Siqueiros (1896-1974)
Mexican artist - painter, graphic artist and muralist , political activist , a member of the Communist movement.

Cardboard - Oil, a copy was made in 1970 .

Dear experts , share opinions, estimates !

Thank you in advance !

Santa · 25.10.2011, 22:58

Цитата:

Сообщение от Stuart

copy number 1:

Siemiradzki Ippolitovich Henry (1843-1902)

Polish and Russian artist, is one of the leading representatives of Russian academic .

Цитата:

Сообщение от Stuart

criticizing the proportion of course

Цитата:

Сообщение от Stuart

copy was made in 1939.

Feeble attempts to "touch the beautiful"

Alas, alas.

>

Stuart · 25.10.2011, 23:11

Цитата:

Сообщение от Santa

Weak attempts to "touch the beautiful"

Alas, alas.

Already become interesting!)

tivat · 25.10.2011, 23:38

[QUOTE=Stuart; 1820083]is becoming interesting!)[/QUOTE]

Compare the first one (Rom. Village)

Omsk Regional Museum of Fine Arts.
Mikhail Vrubel

Stuart · 26.10.2011, 00:21

tivat,
I think that the copy is made quite skillfully, rather the most fundamental difference is that the pictures of the copy in terrible lighting , so the shades it is warm ( yellow ). What about painting itself there are of course minor differences .. While I appreciate more as a lover than a pro. So try to keep quiet and listen to that still others will say experts .

Santa · 26.10.2011, 00:38

Цитата:

Сообщение от Stuart; 1820293"

I think that a copy is made quite masterly

Stuart, I do not want to offend you , believe me

>
But you better not think so (at least , the "free copy"

> G. Semiradsky )
It's not a photo ..
Just what you 've written

Цитата:

Сообщение от Stuart; 1819923"

Siemiradzki Ippolitovich Henry (1843-1902)
one of the the largest representatives of the Russian academic art .

Let's not offend the spirit of Henry Semiradsky, you put up the discussion of "copy" .

Цитата:

Сообщение от Stuart; 1820293"

While I appreciate more as a lover ,

For this you will not blame anyone ..
Do you like - and it's great .

Stuart · 26.10.2011, 00:49

Santa,

Do not even think to offend G. Semiradsky - This is a truly great artist!

Speaking about the copy I just wanted to say that writing a good artist) ...

Popravochka ...

Santa · 26.10.2011, 00:59

Цитата:

Сообщение от Stuart; 1820363"

Speaking of the copy I just wanted to say that writing a good master ) ...

Rather, it is not a master , just - a decent artist .. artist ..
Something had happened ( color ) .. something - not ( Figure).
But in general , a normal picture (without the " binding Semiradsky )

>
Siemiradzki - academic genius .. and this says it all

>

Игорь Гурьев · 26.10.2011, 03:22

In this free copies Semiradsky nothing shameful there.

Even more than that, there is almost no Semiradsky sweetness.

The picture on the fan, such as for holiday homes, expensive, not worth it, but do not throw out as a ...

25.10.2011, 22:01	Язык оригинала: Русский #1
Stuart Пользователь Регистрация: 21.10.2011 Адрес: Москва Сообщений: 35 Спасибо: 22 Поблагодарили 15 раз(а) в 10 сообщениях Репутация: 30	Interesting up with world famous artists. Good day to all ! Maybe I'm just a little is not the topic ... Stocks stumbled into some interesting copies of the known world masters in the first place I would like to hear the opinion of experts as the quality of copies, perhaps to some estimates, the share of criticism is certainly not without it. The copy number 1: Siemiradzki Ippolitovich Henry (1843-1902) Polish and Russian artist, one of the largest representatives of the Russian academic art. Canvas - Oil, a copy was made in 1939. Fragments of a little blurred (shooting without a tripod ) , but in general shows the level of performance . Copy number 2: David Alfaro Siqueiros (1896-1974) Mexican artist - painter, graphic artist and muralist , political activist , a member of the Communist movement. Cardboard - Oil, a copy was made in 1970 . Dear experts , share opinions, estimates ! Thank you in advance !

25.10.2011, 23:38	Язык оригинала: Русский #4
tivat Banned Регистрация: 25.01.2010 Адрес: Россия, Санкт-Петербург Сообщений: 685 Спасибо: 1,264 Поблагодарили 1,593 раз(а) в 587 сообщениях Репутация: 3233	[QUOTE=Stuart; 1820083]is becoming interesting!)[/QUOTE] Compare the first one (Rom. Village) Omsk Regional Museum of Fine Arts. Mikhail Vrubel Миниатюры Последний раз редактировалось tivat; 25.10.2011 в 23:48.

26.10.2011, 00:21	Язык оригинала: Русский #5
Stuart Пользователь Регистрация: 21.10.2011 Адрес: Москва Сообщений: 35 Спасибо: 22 Поблагодарили 15 раз(а) в 10 сообщениях Репутация: 30	tivat, I think that the copy is made quite skillfully, rather the most fundamental difference is that the pictures of the copy in terrible lighting , so the shades it is warm ( yellow ). What about painting itself there are of course minor differences .. While I appreciate more as a lover than a pro. So try to keep quiet and listen to that still others will say experts . Последний раз редактировалось Stuart; 26.10.2011 в 00:34.

26.10.2011, 00:49	Язык оригинала: Русский #7
Stuart Пользователь Регистрация: 21.10.2011 Адрес: Москва Сообщений: 35 Спасибо: 22 Поблагодарили 15 раз(а) в 10 сообщениях Репутация: 30	Santa, Do not even think to offend G. Semiradsky - This is a truly great artist! Speaking about the copy I just wanted to say that writing a good artist) ... Popravochka ... Последний раз редактировалось Stuart; 26.10.2011 в 01:02.

Похожие темы
Тема	Автор	Разделы	Ответов	Последние сообщения
Album-monograph "World through the eyes of the artist" to become a famous academician MV Alpatova	operator	Art Kaleidoscope	13	22.03.2011 20:46
Artists of the World	Тютчев	Exhibitions and events	0	28.01.2011 03:10
Quotes and sayings of famous artists	Жар-птица	Artists, artworks, art history	1	18.09.2010 18:00
Raphael to Renoir: Exhibition of paintings by famous artists from the collection of Jean Bona	Marina56	Exhibitions and events	0	24.03.2009 02:13
Продам: Paintings by famous artists	PETALCO	Sell	14	23.09.2008 17:48

26.10.2011, 03:22	Язык оригинала: Русский #9
Игорь Гурьев Гуру Регистрация: 01.07.2009 Адрес: город П. Сообщений: 4,939 Спасибо: 6,544 Поблагодарили 6,620 раз(а) в 2,829 сообщениях Репутация: 13305	In this free copies Semiradsky nothing shameful there. Even more than that, there is almost no Semiradsky sweetness. The picture on the fan, such as for holiday homes, expensive, not worth it, but do not throw out as a ...