In the Ministry of Culture. Interview questions

[Vladimir]

Then sent to the Ministry of Culture of the list of questions to arrange an interview. It's not fast, but in the meantime essence of the case, I suggest to see forum users questions. It may have something to add? What else to ask advise useful?

The questions themselves - below:

1. One of the factors limiting Russian art market - an acute shortage of supply - that is, objects in the market turnover. Reasons - historical. Many private collections were nationalized and things settled down in the store. One of the ways out of this situation - the audit storerooms and selling items at auction by the state, the "double" and items that do not have a high cultural value. How reasonable and believable do you see such a scenario?

2. The liberalization of the import of cultural property (now toll free) for individuals for personal use very positive impact on the domestic arts. But the ban on the export of certain types of antiques remains a significant negative factor hindering the purchase on the market. In the era of globalization, the measure seems obvious anachronism. Are there any plans to liberalize the export of antiques?

3. In our country, there is no art fair truly international scale (comparable to Art Basel, TEFAF, etc.) However, it is known that these are not only beneficial to the national culture collectibles, but the influx of tourism. It is no accident Qatar buys Cezanne for $ 250 million, and the Middle East poses a contemporary art fair schedule. Does the Ministry of Culture to support themselves or to initiate calls such an important event in Russia?

4. Ministry of Culture gives accreditation expert historical and cultural heritage. This is the case of historic buildings and other facilities. Does the Ministry of Culture, the accreditation of experts on antiques? As today arranged relationship expert antiques and the Ministry of Culture?

5. Does the initiative of the Ministry of compulsory liability insurance for experts in antiques (as is done for assessors)?

6. In 2013, non-profit organizations will provide grants for creative projects in the sphere of culture. Have the timing of application, who and what criteria will select projects?

7. The prospect of an art collective investment funds, private wealth management structures will require the adoption of federal standards for evaluating works of art. Does the ministry in developing the standard?

8. Ministry's website is regularly updated section that contains news about the stolen art objects. But there is no publicly available database. Do you plan to create a national database of stolen items Level Art Loss Register?

9. What measures the Ministry considers the priorities for improving the infrastructure of the national art market?

10. Do you plan to facilitate cross-border movement for show? Private organizers who tried to import or export from Russia exhibition, face absurd difficulties. It would seem, not the suspicious transaction becomes extremely time-consuming due to the complicated customs clearance and other bureaucracy. Without high museum cover (Tretyakov level) of plans to bring the private exhibition organizers soon abandoned.

11. Is the project legalization of market circulation Soviet orders? Measure many today consider anachronistic generating criminal black market.

12. In Moscow in 2012, the authorities had closed the regular art fair "Art Manege" and "Hudgraf." Participation in them could afford and galleries average hand, and contemporary artists with their projects. Now they do not, nothing in return offered. Ministry planning to help run the site are available for artists and galleries, to replace lost?

13. For many years, the idea of ​​an enabling environment for patrons. Our legislation does not favor patronage. It was believed that, should give privileges - and the culture will be used for tax optimization schemes. As a result, today the sponsorship of private traders to become such a headache that any such intention of the people had forgotten. Even elementary desire to sponsor an exhibition of a wealthy man (eg, in the Tretyakov Gallery) fraught with serious accounting problems. Does the ministry to resolve this issue?

14. We have for some years continued crisis in the contemporary art. His weak position and abroad. We're losing the competition, while some other states make up their galleries to the costs of stands, and certainly at the administrative level, give the "green light". Can the Ministry of the Russian participants to provide state aid foreign art exhibitions and fairs?

15. One of the ways to stimulate domestic market of contemporary art could be revived art lottery. Previously, this problem was solved Soviet Union Art Lottery, which was held from the beginning of the 1960s until 1991. Need to work on his hands went to the artists had money to eventually part of the work was intended for resale and formed the secondary market. With the art lottery launched, in particular, the art market is the UK, which now exports culture has become one of the most important economic sectors. How viable do you think is the idea of ​​art lottery in Russia today?

[uriart]

Vladimir, I would like to get you on my behalf and asked a question.

Designed the pattern for temporary importation.

It imported in 2009.

Quite to the import declaration for export?

Or do we need to take another permit for the export of the Ministry of Culture?

Thank you!

[олег назаров]

Vladimir, and who specifically addressed these issues?
The Medina?

[Коллекционер-любитель]

Good topic. Questions are correct.
You can add:
1.Vsem know that now in Russia most of the antique market is in a "gray zone." Revision of reservists , the decision to sell antiques from the store by the state at auction, to create favorable conditions for patrons , optimization of insurance liability expert antiques and artdilerov - all these (and many other aspects , address and resolve issues of improving the circulation of antiques and antique market withdrawal of shadow) require legislative solutions . Does the Ministry of Culture and the development of such a law to legislative initiative in the State Duma ?

[Vladimir]

Сообщение от Oleg Nazarov, 2447161

Vladimir, and who specifically addressed these issues?
Medinan?

Question: We have on all fronts, so one particular destination can and can not do.

Added after 26 minutes

Сообщение от uriart; 2447151"

Vladimir, I would like you on my behalf and asked a question.
Designed the pattern for temporary importation.
It imported in 2009.
Quite to the import declaration for export ?
Or do we need to take another permit for the export of the Ministry of Culture ?
Thank you !

OK, but in the future it would be good to gather a crowd numerous legal questions members of the forum . Separate important conversation.

[Коллекционер-любитель]

Сообщение от Vladimir; 2447031"

For many years, the idea of ​​an enabling environment for patrons. Our legislation does not favor patronage. It was believed that, should give privileges - and the culture will be used for tax optimization schemes. As a result, today the sponsorship of private traders to become such a headache that any such intention of the people had forgotten. Even elementary desire to sponsor an exhibition of a wealthy man (eg, in the Tretyakov Gallery) fraught with serious accounting problems. Does the ministry to resolve this issue?

RBC daily on February 1, 2013
"Gazprom", football and culture[/B]
Before making the bill "On Sponsorship" in the State Duma to discuss it at the council for culture under the Speaker of the lower chamber of parliament, Sergei Naryshkin. Of Sports and Arts agreed that such a law is necessary, provided that it can not be used to evade taxes. The deputies did not argue with them.
The meeting in the Golden Hall of the State Duma on Thursday differed unusually high level of culture controversy: filmmakers, professors, producers and artists do not interrupt each other, as is usually the case in the Duma.
One of the most prominent speakers of parliament, head of the Committee on Budget and Taxes Andrei Makarov, finally found a worthy partner for discussion. True, the tone of conversation, he asked pessimistic.
"Culture is seen as an opportunity to show what you're cool, or to avoid taxes," - was strict, Mr. Makarov warned that the draft law to important right to talk about the nature of the target allocated money. "As soon as we're talking about tax preferences, we must at the same time suggest a mechanism of control. And it will be the slogan" Peace. Labor. May ", - explained the problem head of the committee, noting that no reproach to the slogan, but it is still nothing.
The law will require a second reading, and other additions. One of the biggest philanthropists in the country - VTB Bank, according to his representative, the head of the public relations department of public relations and marketing Maksimenkova Valeria, I would like to receive any signals from the public and the authorities, in which direction to issue funds. "For example, purposefully, rural library," - said Mr. Maksimenkov.
Makarov deputy saw another problem: lack of officials. According to him, about how to build a circuit of patronage, "can not agree among themselves the Ministry of Finance and Economic Development, and the Ministry of culture and did not." "The Ministry of Culture, we have" - ​​just in case corrected Mr. Naryshkin.
"The proposed mechanism is democratic, when the patron chooses where he wants to send funds, he sees a growth point," - responded to this proponent of the bill, MP and soloist Mariinsky theater Maria Maksakova-Igenbergs.
Igor Matvienko, producer and composer, has complained that the major sponsorship money is spent on the global trend - football. "Gazprom", capitalization has fallen by half, trying to create a new football season ", - said Mr. Matvienko, stressing that on the way to the heights of sport we are facing a collapse of culture." People do not know a third and a quart, and we will take in college in Gnesinka was first on the Composition Department shortfall this year, "- said the producer.
Strongly opposed to the concept of the bill introduced by a representative spoke of the Public Chamber Larisa Zelkova. She believes that it is necessary to make a special section in the law about the charity and not to write a new law. But most of yesterday was for to prepare a separate initiative.
The bill, which, as noted by Mr. Naryshkin, will soon be submitted to the Duma, previously received feedback from 45 regions of the country, of which 36 with full support and only four with negative evaluations.

[K-Maler]

Сообщение от Vladimir; 2447031"

3 . In our country, there is no art fair truly international scale (comparable to Art Basel, TEFAF , etc.) However, it is known that these are not only beneficial to the national culture collectibles, but the influx of tourism. It is no accident Qatar buys Cezanne for $ 250 million , and the Middle East poses a contemporary art fair schedule . Does the Ministry of Culture to support themselves or to initiate calls such an important event in Russia?

Is the right idea. Muscovites have come up with where to place , and in Petersburg without " cause" while New Holland " ...

Added after 12 minutes

Сообщение от Vladimir

It may have something to add?
What else to ask advise useful?

Toughen the penalties for counterfeiting.
And to limit the number of experts who have Art and individuals (with a degree) or artistic (to "the eyes are) education.

[Vladimir]

Сообщение от K-Maler

toughen the penalties for counterfeiting.

There's so responsible and serious.
But it is not inevitable.

Added after 2 minutes

Сообщение от amateur collector , 2451281"

" Culture is seen as an opportunity to show what you're cool , or to avoid taxes ," - was strict Mr. Makarov

And it helps to evade taxes , it is not explained? In this case, any tax incentives should be , or what it will be different from the current stagnant situation?

[Коллекционер-любитель]

Engaged verbiage - the Ministry of Culture of the legislative work is eliminated.
Now philanthropy - means assistance in the acquisition of sports stars.
If the law and will be - then again, underdeveloped, not covering the range of issues discussed in circulation Vladimir.

[Vladimir]

Сообщение от amateur collector , 2451431"

If the law and will be - then again, underdeveloped , not covering the range of issues

That's just wondering, who is preparing a preliminary examination of the law, which experts drawn from the professional community who identifies weaknesses and "holes "? Well, if people need help?