Imam Shamil, who is the author? - Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство

levkor · 26.10.2011, 14:44

Dear forum users !
My friend has a picture which he had inherited from his grandfather. He really wants to know the author's work. Historians and critics say that shows the Imam Shamil, the time of Alexander 1, during the war in the Caucasus. Sfotkat . Praised the " academic art " as they called it Pyshta MJ and museum staff , but essentially nothing to say they could not. Should I invest in the expertise and who is the author ? Tell me, please !

Кирилл Сызранский · 26.10.2011, 15:58

Цитата:

Сообщение от levkor; 1821043"

say that depicted Imam Shamil, the time of Alexander -1

And this is where Imam Shamil rides ? What is the landscape around that for architecture ?
At the village Gunib , for example, it bears little resemblance .

And in the days of Alexander - a " no Imam Shamil has been, vostanie Chechens led by Ghazi Muhammad raised in 1831, already under the Emperor Nicholas .

levkor · 26.10.2011, 16:37

Cyril Syzran,

Thank you for the info!
Of course, with Nicholas.

Maybe it's not Shamil - I just passed on the information received from local critics.
However, the question of authorship, unfortunately, it does not solve, and it remains an open question.

Кирилл Сызранский · 26.10.2011, 16:46

levkor, in my opinion, the painting depicts a Harun al-Rashid, a scene from "1001 Nights".

levkor · 27.10.2011, 04:53

Once again thank you for your participation.

When I saw the picture on the monitor, noticed some characters ...

Maybe they mean something?
Or maybe just struck me.

Tsop · 27.10.2011, 19:28

Цитата:

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran

village at Gunib, for example, it bears little resemblance.

Just do not Gunib

>

And I do not Caucasus

Кирилл Сызранский · 27.10.2011, 19:38

Цитата:

Сообщение от Tsop

And I do not Caucasus

Of course.

Some fantasy landscapes and architectural aspects.

Bridge or aqueduct there gave some antique.

levkor · 28.10.2011, 15:18

This means that local experts were wrong.
It happens in every one.

Maybe they were wrong, and yet another picture with the caption Shishkin?
They said that such a picture it does not have a fake, most likely, although there have similar stories.

It makes sense to show it here?

And sorry for the trouble.

Кирилл Сызранский · 28.10.2011, 15:32

Цитата:

Сообщение от levkor

It makes sense to show it here?

That's how you want.

Цитата:

Сообщение от levkor

And I'm sorry for your trouble.

And what is anxiety?

In what way?
Who?

>

levkor · 28.10.2011, 15:56

Well, since you are wasting your time ...

My wife - a historian.
It shamed me for my opus and was impressed with your knowledge and learning.

And about Shishkin - you want to show, and suddenly - a miracle and something worthwhile?

This is probably a branch of the examination or may be in the same?

26.10.2011, 14:44	Язык оригинала: Русский #1
levkor Новичок Регистрация: 26.10.2011 Сообщений: 9 Спасибо: 1 Поблагодарили 0 раз(а) в 0 сообщениях Репутация: 0	Imam Shamil, who is the author? Dear forum users ! My friend has a picture which he had inherited from his grandfather. He really wants to know the author's work. Historians and critics say that shows the Imam Shamil, the time of Alexander 1, during the war in the Caucasus. Sfotkat . Praised the " academic art " as they called it Pyshta MJ and museum staff , but essentially nothing to say they could not. Should I invest in the expertise and who is the author ? Tell me, please ! Миниатюры

26.10.2011, 16:37	Язык оригинала: Русский #3
levkor Новичок Регистрация: 26.10.2011 Сообщений: 9 Спасибо: 1 Поблагодарили 0 раз(а) в 0 сообщениях Репутация: 0	Cyril Syzran, Thank you for the info! Of course, with Nicholas. Maybe it's not Shamil - I just passed on the information received from local critics. However, the question of authorship, unfortunately, it does not solve, and it remains an open question. Последний раз редактировалось levkor; 26.10.2011 в 16:38. Причина: Добавлено сообщение

27.10.2011, 04:53	Язык оригинала: Русский #5
levkor Новичок Регистрация: 26.10.2011 Сообщений: 9 Спасибо: 1 Поблагодарили 0 раз(а) в 0 сообщениях Репутация: 0	Once again thank you for your participation. When I saw the picture on the monitor, noticed some characters ... Maybe they mean something? Or maybe just struck me. Миниатюры

Похожие темы
Тема	Автор	Разделы	Ответов	Последние сообщения
Who is the author ?????	antik2010	Costs, valuation, attribution	3	17.03.2011 10:11
Who is the author?	eva777	Costs, valuation, attribution	5	13.10.2010 14:28
They say Polenov help assess	neborator	Costs, valuation, attribution	37	12.07.2010 20:29
Who is the author?	тарас1980	Appraisal	2	17.04.2010 11:35
Who is the author?	usynin2	Costs, valuation, attribution	9	01.02.2010 19:57

26.10.2011, 16:46	Язык оригинала: Русский #4
Кирилл Сызранский Гуру Регистрация: 26.07.2008 Адрес: РФ, Самара Сообщений: 75,397 Спасибо: 27,867 Поблагодарили 55,328 раз(а) в 24,281 сообщениях Записей в дневнике: 133 Репутация: 102388	levkor, in my opinion, the painting depicts a Harun al-Rashid, a scene from "1001 Nights".

28.10.2011, 15:18	Язык оригинала: Русский #8
levkor Новичок Регистрация: 26.10.2011 Сообщений: 9 Спасибо: 1 Поблагодарили 0 раз(а) в 0 сообщениях Репутация: 0	This means that local experts were wrong. It happens in every one. Maybe they were wrong, and yet another picture with the caption Shishkin? They said that such a picture it does not have a fake, most likely, although there have similar stories. It makes sense to show it here? And sorry for the trouble.

28.10.2011, 15:56	Язык оригинала: Русский #10
levkor Новичок Регистрация: 26.10.2011 Сообщений: 9 Спасибо: 1 Поблагодарили 0 раз(а) в 0 сообщениях Репутация: 0	Well, since you are wasting your time ... My wife - a historian. It shamed me for my opus and was impressed with your knowledge and learning. And about Shishkin - you want to show, and suddenly - a miracle and something worthwhile? This is probably a branch of the examination or may be in the same?