Borovikovsky?

[I-V]

Here's a thumbnail (№ 1) from the private collection offers a Munich auction http://www.kettererkunst.com/details...03&anummer=408 in May.

Lot: 39

Russland

Porträt einer jungen Adeligen. 19th century.

Oil on zinc.
Monogrammed "CB" (or Cyrillic "SV") in lower right. 15,8 x 12,4 cm (6,2 x 4,8 in), in oval. [CB].


But the portraits of Grand Duchess Alexandra Pavlovna Romanova (daughter of Paul I) on the Internet ( except the first, which is an auction ) Borovikovsky hand (if you believe the Internet) )

The question , I suppose, all clear - Borovikovsky or not?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от IV

Borovikovsky or not?

More likely a miniature copy of his paintings.

[K-Maler]

Сообщение от IV

Borovikovsky or not?

The second is similar to Borovikovsky, but not "live" is hard to say.
It is not known how much interfered restorers.

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от K-Maler; 2549551"

The second is similar to Borovikovsky ,

Bravo! Here in the State Tretyakov Gallery also think so. > Already since 1939. And until 1939, to believe in the Pushkin Museum. Pushkin , and before that - the ... (however, recount the history of the collection led the existence of a portrait . Book. Alexandra Pavlovna, the Palatine of Hungary , I for some reason do not want. Books has not been canceled ).

[K-Maler]

Сообщение от Dilettante, 2549841

Bravo!
Here in the State Tretyakov Gallery also think so.

And in fact, "bravo": my opinion the second time coincided with the opinion of experts famous museums (as in the case of "Kustodiev"), only the second time for some reason you did not like.

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от K-Maler; 2549971"

Indeed , " bravo ": my opinion is the second time coincided with the opinion of experts famous museums (as in the case of " Kustodiev "), only the second time for some reason you did not like.

I did not like ? Strange conclusion , however.
I am somewhat surprised that you have no reason, all of a sudden began to speak thoughtfully about the possibility of the true picture , already ( attention to the screen !) '74 kept in the Tretyakov Gallery, and absolutely no one causing the slightest doubt. >
Just in case - explain ( personally for you , because no one else in similar needs no explanation ) : In the series of figurative painting is placed in a standard .
In this regard, I would like to know: what do you personally think about the true picture of the Bogolyubov donated Saratov Art Museum by Bogolyubov ? Surely here your opinion "is the same "? It risks becoming the opening decades ...

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Dilettante, 2550011

what do you personally think about the true picture of the Bogolyubov donated Saratov Art Museum by Bogolyubov?

.............
....

Сообщение от K-Maler

is not "live" is hard to say.

 
>

[Игорь Гурьев]

It is clear that the germ.
Auction - languid and helplessness copy of Borovikovsky, though written much later, as I see it ...