[annagavr]

Сообщение от acetate

Not at all, " Kazan" - means to emphasize individuality, singularity , exclusivity , uniqueness of this phenomenon , and it is the Russian avant-garde. Look , I wrote about Syzransky term " Kazan vanguard" , or rather wrote Galeev - Syzransky found .
  Introduced - a new term , you know ...... for art , and then read what I wrote earlier, why is it happening today , turned out great illustration .
  And for convenience - the Kazan avant-garde artists . All specialists are
 refer to the " Russian avant-garde " art history as a definition, and not territorial , at least from the time of its appearance , and if someone thinks differently , it is a problem of its cultural training .

In general, do not understand the essence of the dispute.
Galeev took understudied formation pulled into the light , designed , packaged , hung tag " Kazan vanguard" , invested in short - and now he's the holder of the brand. What can I say ? Good for you !

And someone's Wishlist - well , well, people have the right to choose . Vaughn Deleuze argued that man is a machine desires) )

By the way, Turkestan avant-garde - the term has a right to life ?

The exhibition catalog introduces the distinctive and striking phenomenon of cultural and artistic life of the USSR - the works of Russian artists who lived and worked in the Central Asian republics in the 1920s and 30s , a combined total phenomenon of " Turkestan avant-garde" .

For a catalog of the exhibition is not distinct and artistic ornate style - is what we need . The text is very accurate in vocabulary and intonation in terms of genre hit. Structurally, the narrative built logically and in proportion : soft historical picture , stories about artists without artkriticheskih ambitious statements. Overall, decent , and I would say , a noble tone . Even the term " Turkestan avant-garde" is introduced carefully and with respect to the invisible opponents.

Doctor of Arts, member of the Academy of Fine Arts

Republic of Uzbekistan A. Khakimov

" Turkestan avant-garde ", first outlined and labeled with such certainty can be oharatkerizovan as unique organic fusion of innovative discoveries brought to the 1920s on land the future of Central Asia Russian avant-garde young animals . Absorbing the latest trends of the West, and put them in Russia in one of the most remarkable events of the XX century art , they faced here with the ancient and deeply peculiar national traditions of the East . The result of this interaction was " Turkestan avant-garde" .

Doctor of Arts , member of the Russian Academy of Arts

MA Chegodaeva .

The basic meaning of Russian artists in the development of art in the Central Asian region was that they did not just participated in its formation , but also brought to this process most modern trends . The result of their work was a unique artistic phenomenon , the authors show here that offer to give the name " Turkestan avant-garde" .

Art critic Adele Di Ruocco

Added after 9 minutes

Сообщение от Maroussia

from the Vitebsk Art School

You just were not Kazan . I advise you to visit .

And Vitebsk art school was established in 1919, if the wiki is not lying to us .

Added after 13 minutes

Сообщение от Maroussia

NOT TO -LO " Moscow and St. Petersburg etc. . vanguards »

There was not there. However, there were localized on the geography of the group to include the e - course to (sic!) to RUSSIAN AVANT-GARDE !

Added after 32 minutes

Сообщение от Maroussia

I do not know what I was thinking about the science of history , when it decided to divide the artists and artistic movements are not on the national or " local " basis , and by nationality , and impressionism they - by default - French expressionism - German and Russian avant-garde turned ( because it emerged and developed in the Russian Empire ) . Not considered irresponsible art historians burst of national identity in Ukraine and Tatarstan .

In scientific ( natural and Humanities ) - "local " definition is common.