[Сталевар]

Сообщение от Allena

Stalevar, is not only black and white. Simonovsky verses in this case does not figure as a typical example of propaganda. There is nothing wrong in this case because I do not have, but it was so, and if the poem was played for which it is the role of (what is no doubt one iota), it means that it was the right cause.

The question is about something else: not the people thrown into this meat grinder, divided into "black" and "white". We all were born after the war, and how much we read or watched movies or listened to the memories, we still can not imagine the state of those people who have had it for a test.

Man - he was always a man is only in such difficult times manifests its essence. And hardly anyone can predict how behaves this or that man at the front. Someone in essence - a sadist, someone - a looter, a shopkeeper, someone in the child's fire can not, and the other will burn right and left, drowning out the voice of his conscience by the words "fog of war", but some a provincial accountant will be noble man - a man in the worst times of my life.

Do not divide the warring people into good and bad. Psychology man at war - is complicated. This is now a soldier specially prepared, and then this thought much (in the modern sense of the term). Propaganda was, but still some, but now everything is different.

The memory will never go away - neither of the crimes, nor about the heroism, nor infamy, nor of the nobility. But people are people are always. Another question: what?

Read the memories of the artist Leonid Rabicheva. he was a boy at the front hit. Just say: read it will be very unpleasant. I have trouble myself forced to the end to finish reading, but a man published is repentance, because to live with this in mind it is intolerable. And how many (both sides) who publicly repented, and at night, these nightmares are going through again? most ordinary people, only the war a broken?

"The Island" Loungin look. Not each of those broken by the good fortune to be heard in lifelong penance for a moment of fear and cowardice displayed by the war, boy. And the units must have been given to pay their bills here, as the hero of the film.

Alain, not divide people into black and white? Ie all people - gray impersonal mass?
And if a person divides the black and white, he was promoting.
Indeed, until the war will not pass, you will be tolerant. And how find yourself at war - immediately priobretesh clear views, and not vague tolerantovschinu.

Movies Lungina I watched everything.

Alain interested in your opinion on the Chechen war? There, too, all the people? No black and white?