Гуру
Регистрация: 28.03.2008
Сообщений: 9,415
Спасибо: 1,532
Поблагодарили 29,854 раз(а) в 6,714 сообщениях
Репутация: 27272
|
Цитата:
Сообщение от Santa; 1787163"
, "Lolita" by Vladimir Nabokov and "One Hundred Years of Solitude" by Gabriel Garcia Marquez, you should seriously consider the presence of They promote pedophilia, said in an interview, "Russian news service," Archpriest Vsevolod Chaplin.
|
Was there a boy?
Цитата:
Сообщение от Cyril Syzran; 1789713"
He wants to seriously study the presence of books in Nabokov, and García Márquez promote pedophilia.
You are a subject that read?
|
You just gave a rebuff to the theme "I'm 76 years old and I'm tired"
Now step on the same rake.
Question - what is actually said Vsevolod Chaplin?
It reads:
Цитата:
You've probably heard the news that the Russian Orthodox Church has accused the classics - Gabriel Garcia Marquez and Vladimir Nabokov - in promoting pedophilia? I have a few days reading this message in different languages and do not cease to admire. Here Forbs talks about attacks on the literature: «Russian Orthodox Church slams two acclaimed authors». But Culture Minister defends writers: "Alexander Avdeev does not see the works of" Lolita "and" One Hundred Years of Solitude "promoting pedophilia, but did not blame the Archpriest Vsevolod Chaplin calls for surrender the books, while agreeing with the idea of a representative of the Russian Orthodox churches that need tough fight against pedophilia. " Scandal!
But let me tell you all the same as it was ...
September 27, 2011 I had the radio station, "Russian news service" took a serious conversation with the chairman of the Synodal Department for Cooperation of Church and Society of the Moscow Patriarchate Archpriest Vsevolod Chaplin. Arguing about one of his recent statements that the pedophiles, they say, raise your head and go into the open medianastuplenie.
ROC drew attention to two articles, which roam the web: the first - the manifesto "boylaverov", the second - an article from the magazine "Sexology and sexual pathology" of pedophilia, head of the department of forensic medicine and law Northern State Medical University, Gennady Derjaguin. Father Vsevolod regarded these publications as a promotion of pedophilia brought down on them and the power of his indignation.
The essence of our disagreement with the archpriest was that the manifesto "boylaverov" was published in 1997, and an article in a scientific journal to refer to the propaganda, I would never become. Why ROC noticed just now and it is in these works, and I'm trying to figure out.
At the end of our conversation, to demonstrate the degree of absurdity, which is reachable, I was asked. I will give him verbatim: «Nabokov -" Lolita "Marquez in the book" One Hundred Years of Solitude "also found similar stories ... This is propaganda of pedophilia? ». A Vsevolod Chaplin:" Let's explore this. I think it's also a matter for serious study. " Everything! So in the media and a legend was born that the ROC is against writers, who are called among the greatest in the twentieth century.
to emphasize that Chaplin and not say a word about fiction and did not name any names. But ... He questioned the recognized writers and works. That was enough.
The next day, judging by the news, the country woke up in the Middle Ages. "Shakespeare may prohibit the promotion of pedophilia", "ROC declared war against Marquez and Nabokov" - read the headlines. Mikhail Shvydkoi warned that this story may impact on the image of Russia, Eduard Limonov, was indignant: "What will they do with Nabokov, Marquez? What banned book? These people do not realize that they look like gentlemen, had fallen from the tree of progress. "
Anyone not care that there is said Chaplin, and "whether there was a boy" really is. Everything that was not about the Putin-Medvedev-Kudrin, seemed a breath of fresh air, and Father Vsevolod with the whole Russian Orthodox Church is literally torn to pieces in the press.
The idea of Chaplin's alleged instantly appeared supporters who began to demand: "Prevent this poshlyatinu!". On the other hand fell in the desire to destroy the prosecution world culture: "The inquisitors! Obscurantists! ".
I, being the unwitting instigator of the conflagration, was given only a diva. Yes, and the Father Vsevolod, apparently, this turn of events did not expect. Secular dogma rebelled against the dogmas of the church, atheist turned against the faithful, the Orthodox began to accuse the forces of darkness in the desire to put the war on pedophilia in the mainstream of the struggle with the literature.
It turns out that confront members of Russian society is possible without the conspiracy at all. Conspiracy no spin is not necessary. We are pleased to enter into a clinch and the chest of each other to shake. Give the only reason! Even if this opportunity is 99 percent will consist of fiction.
I confess that after his conversation with Vsevolod Chaplin, I would like to write an article that the church is ready to question everything - even recognized around the world literary works (for which, incidentally, also gives the Nobel Prize). I wanted to write about the chasm that had been laid between secular society and the ROC. But I could not imagine, that could result in our discussion with the archpriest. Excuse me, but here I want to stand up all the forces already in the church. Misrepresented the demons!
But there are stories of this poluanekdoticheskoy very tangible and positive results. So much was said about the last days of Marquez and Nabokov, we are so often referred to "Lolita" and "One Hundred Years of Solitude," which even in very distant from the literature of people had a desire to explore the issues in dispute. For that curse? Why marvel?
And even if the ROC doubt morality of these works, I think, no Vsevolod Chaplin, nor anyone else would not be opposed to the kitchens of discussions about moral character Humbert Humbert and Buendia family, and not participants of a reality show. Amen!
Material prepared by Vladimir Karpov, Alexander Gas
|
|