Цитата:
|
Сообщение от AlexanderG
Na moi vzgliad, eto prosto remeslo ik iskusstvu otnosheniia ne imeet.
Mozet byt 'ia pereel etogo v Au i NZ, no interesa vsio eto lichno u menia ne vyzyvaet.
Kstati, imel bezresul'tatnuiu besedu so svoim professorom po istorii iskusstv, gde pytalsia vyiasnit 'chem otlichaetsia odinakovye po kachestvu ispolneniia raboty is Afriki ili, naprimer, sdelannye nemtsami ili russkimi dlia tolkuchki.
Otveta ne poluchil
|
...
Цитата:
|
Сообщение от AlexanderG
Art-lover: The gulf between the consciousness of modern European and African artist and magician are not so insurmountable.
Mozno seriozno posporit 'po etomu povodu. Is moego opyta - sovershenno ne preodolima.
A zachem preodolevat '? My sovsem rasnye.
|
...
Цитата:
Сообщение от AlexanderG
U nas i prodolzitel'nost 'zisni pobol'she. Tsivilizatsiia ne est 'zlo i dushitel'.
No esli komu-to hochetsia nazad v peschery ...
Iskusstvo imeet absoliutnye fisiologicheskie korni
|
AlexanderG, I read your posts in this topic, and realized why the professor is difficult to answer your questions.
First of all, because you already have the answers.
You close the positivistic approach to life, and travel through time and space to the origins of artistic form and spirit, which gives us the possibility of creative people that are close to nature, you probably are not the most interesting kind of tourism.
Therefore, we will argue about anything.
For me, the physiological roots of the art relative to you - are absolute.
Evidently, you think in the comprehensive progress of civilization, for me it is obvious that in a series of historical epochs of civilization may be accompanied by a spiritual regression.
For you, the absence or presence of ethnic culture developed aesthetic terminology is a criterion for distinguishing between savage and civilized formotvorchestva craft fine art, but I remember that age 20y undermined the credibility of Western civilization metadiskursu worked out the art and thus identified a new twist to the sources.
However, I hope, all these differences do not prevent us from being in EXCELLENT relations.
(PS The fact that the Russian artisan could easily repeat an African mask - it does not detract from the dignity of the prototype and its pervoizobretateley. Unique is not a specific mask (if we disregard the question of energy), and the historical fact of birth of great art form).