Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство - Painting imitators Aivazovsky. Help evaluate and determine the author

- Costs, valuation, attribution (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/forumdisplay.php?f=6)

- - Painting imitators Aivazovsky. Help evaluate and determine the author (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/showthread.php?t=27306)

Painting imitators Aivazovsky. Help evaluate and determine the author

Previously, I have such information on this painting (information provided by the deputy. Head. The department of painting the second half of the nineteenth - early twentieth century, Tretyakov Gallery):

Цитата:

Perhaps this picture imitators Aivazovsky. It works by an unknown artist of the late nineteenth - early twentieth century. The signature on the painting can be read as AK (?) - One thousand nine hundred and sixth year. In practice, the expert met the work of artist A. Karzhakina (or A. Karzhavin; signature is not clearly legible) - Sailing ship in the stormy sea, imitators IKAivazovsky. Judging from photos on the plot and some stylistic grounds it is close landscape of the unknown, not in the references to artists, A. Karzhakina (Karzhavin?), The master of the middling sort. Size: eighty-cm per meter. Signed in the lower right corner - in 1906

So I ask you to help with the definition of the author and the approximate cost of the painting. Where it is possible to offer for sale?
Thank you in advance.

Met on the Internet exactly takuyuzhe work entitled "Getting the storm" thin.
Alexander Kalmykov Odisseevich.
In the lower right corner "A.K.1909g.

Nikolai Petrovich.

Цитата:

Сообщение от deputy . Head . the department of painting the second half of the nineteenth - early twentieth century Tretyakov Gallery

Perhaps this pattern imitators Aivazovsky . It works by an unknown artist of the late nineteenth - early twentieth century.

As written by Ushakov's Explanatory Dictionary - EPIGO'N [descendent]
A follower of Mr. . Art ... or that direction , devoid of creative independence .
Ie whoever drew waves and the ship can be called imitator Aivazovsky ? Or not everyone ?

Цитата:

Сообщение от Sveta (Сообщение 368975)

Pre have such information on the pattern (information provided by the deputy . head . the department of painting the second half of the nineteenth - early twentieth century, Tretyakov Gallery ) :

So I ask you to help with the definition of the author and the approximate cost of the painting. Where it is possible to offer for sale ?
Thank you in advance .

Offer your price pollyakov@yandex.ru C SW ...

Цитата:

Сообщение от ANTIK (Сообщение 1620033)

has proposed $ 500

And nothing that the theme of two years ago?
You do not mind the absence of the seller?

ANTIK, in boxing this is called shadow boxing.

Цитата:

Сообщение от Toinen (Сообщение 1620373)

Does not matter that the subject two years ago?
You do not mind the absence of the seller?

ANTIK, in boxing this is called shadow boxing.

A really :D>

http://adinah.wordpress.com/category...%D0%B5%D1%82 / Maybe antik tepr offers?
Possible, and so regarded.

Цитата:

Сообщение от Toinen (Сообщение 1620373)

Does not matter that the subject two years ago?
You do not mind the absence of the seller?

ANTIK, in boxing this is called shadow boxing.

But somehow the dates and have not looked!
Drew attention to the so-as a theme in the work byla.Nu and money offered.

Nicholas Levenko, by Alexander Kalmykov Odisseevicha is a copy of a work of Ivan Aivazovsky.
It is quite natural, since both he and his brother, a famous artist Gregory Odisseevich Kalmykov took lessons from Aivazovsky.

Ivan Aivazovsky The Ship in the Sea " 1888 . ( almost a million $ )
It is strange that the information deputy . Head . the department of painting the second half of the nineteenth - early twentieth century Tretyakov Gallery (if had) , he speaks only of some mythical Karzhavin ,
and there is no mention of this painting Ivan Aivazovsky , no student Aivazovsky
notorious artist AO Kalmykov (1869 - 1929 ).
http://www.korners.com.ua/russian/painters/903