Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство

- Costs, valuation, attribution (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/forumdisplay.php?f=6)

- - Marc Chagall? (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/showthread.php?t=216902)

Hello

Please help me identify a fake, or what?

Watercolor on paper.

Size: 62 x 48 cm

Below the signature and something Russian.

Painting in Europe.

Thank you in advance!

roman99, konchno fake!
Make no mistake.

forgery, and amateur

Цитата:

Сообщение от camertus (Сообщение 2764271)

fake, and amateur

Based on what criteria you specified that fake amateur??

Added after 2 minutes
I would like to hear more opinions members of the forum ..... Please help .....

roman99, take into account:

Цитата:

- How many forgeries of paintings by Marc Chagall appears now? There is a rule : If you want to steal a book from the counter or from the library , so it is well worth it. If the picture of the fake , then she deserves ...

meets the granddaughter of Mrs. artist Meret Meyer- Graber , which today represents the interests of the family Chagall :

- You are right. Indeed , copying artist - the flip side of success. But it was not just copy , but sometimes trying to forge .
We are inundated with counterfeit Chagall . Many are made in Eastern Europe. The peak of this process comes at a time when collapsed "iron curtain " - came the real catastrophe : before the end of the eighties, my mother was a card-index , which recorded a fake paintings grandfather , but now they have three!

Цитата:

The works of famous artists , which are sold at auction , should have special certificates confirming their identity is the author brush .
The authenticity of Chagall's works has the right to confirm a special expert group Chagall Committee, whose headquarters is in Paris. President of the committee is Jean -Louis Prat , and the vice -president - the granddaughter of the great artist Meret Meyer- Graber

(director Marc Chagall Museum in Vitebsk, Lyudmila Khmelnitsky)

http://www.rg.ru/2005/06/02/volshebnik.html - RG 2005

Цитата:

Сообщение от roman99; 2765631 "

I would like to hear more opinions members of the forum ..... Please help .....

roman99, in our lives , there are many unwritten rules.
Let's dress boots on his feet , not on his head.
In the gas tank is filled car fuel, not water .
Train rides on the rails , but not water.
Phone is a communication tool , not a tool for nailing .

Similarly, the rules work in the life of art.
Museums and galleries created to showcase art, not a football game.
Auctions of art created for sale, not for baiting fish.

One of these rules relating to art, is that for the authenticity of authorship, " high profile" names, set up funds.
For Konchalovsky - Konchalovsky Foundation .
For von Jawlensky - Fund Jawlensky .
For Archipenko Archipenko Foundation .
For Chagall - Chagall Foundation .

Replies received oforumchan do not satisfy you , so please contact the Fund Chagall. Do you want to get an accurate answer? - Where to get it 100 %.
It is advisable to take with watercolor . But you have to be prepared that will return there without her. It can be wiped directly into the fund.

There are some exceptions to these rules of life is art.
To confirm the authorship of Malevich's desirable to avoid resorting to the fund Malevich.
To confirm brush Burliuk can not address the Committee Burliuk .
And as it turned out today in the subject of Adrian Richter -
to confirm the authorship of German painters of the 19th century to avoid the examination of Yuri Vakulenko .

Thank you very much .... I have already contacted the fund Chagall, but for the examination must be present in person along with the picture .....

Added after 1 minutes
Thanks to all forum users for their attention ......

roman99, I see you have a question for Burliuk, by Van Dyck, by Korovin, by Modigliani ...

On the edge of the walk, tovarisch probably you, as the Shukshin Egor Prokudin, " money thigh tourniquet ".
<! - ~ 7 ~ ->

Цитата:

Сообщение от roman99 (Сообщение 2763381)

or a fake?

Watercolor on paper.

Forgery, and, straight from the tin ...
There's even granddaughters do not, so ... bad taste

Цитата:

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky (Сообщение 2767161)

roman99, I see you have a question for Burliuk , by Van Dyck , by Korovin , by Modigliani ...

So it , it seems to me that all this luxury is prohibitive - from " kupilnaebaykom ." One person genuinely surprised me - why , they say , you are so expensive , that's the same look, amassed ebay.com, and here's the first names - and there Malevich and Kandinsky , and Chagall , and who not only ... And the prices are loyal and all originals , pryamtak because it is written - rare! original! <! - ~ 1 ~ ->