Please help me to evaluate a couple of pictures
 

Hello,


help me, please, to estimate two pictures.

size in both pictures is identical - the height of blade 32.5, while the width of 25.5

written, according to my opinion dilettante, watercolor.


photos

one:


Вложение 1515431Вложение 1515441Вложение 1515451


two:


Вложение 1515461Вложение 1515471Вложение 1515481


thank you ...

The first picture is worthless , in my opinion .

The second - such as " antique ." Someone carefully glued ( koso! ) old newspaper .
To "old " give .
Although we can not exclude that the picture - before the revolution .

But - no . Neither the mind nor the heart.
Level of brush - very so-so, very faceless written.

Thanks for your reply.

about newspaper and old amused.
feel the eyes guru :)>

it may be worth before this writing, ask where these pictures?))) may well be that the owners know exactly how old are they?)

maybe it's just the impression of a photographic image?)

Why should I ask?
That is, if you like, then say so.

I judge by what I see , as well as on the basis of some experience, some do not usually characteristic of a very young art historians such as yours truly .

You are certainly right. It is very difficult to estimate the age of watercolor pictures , but as regards the level of painting, I fully agree with Guriev , Igor. And then, as both look tylniki watercolors, suggesting an attempt to fraud the time of writing .

There's this old advertising sticker collages in the style of the 1920s.

And keeping her suspiciously good, the ads.

Now that everything else is so shabby.
And why not?
her that, to tie in harrow harrowing?

The fact that the second tylnik watercolor smeared with something white , and then the top was glued label store fur (? ) With the text in the old spelling ( so that nothing seemed) . On the right are stains that are cut off by the label and re- emerge from under her, leaving no trace on the label .
First watercolor sitting in someone else's mount ( not in size) and in another frame.
Tylnik over most watercolors for 50 years .