Riddle
 

There is such a nice job.
Wood, oil, 17.8h24.1sm
As a signature is read Shishkin (? So wish!) Or not?
I can not exactly understand. 1879.
Shishkin this year was already living in Russia and Latin as a sign something was not he with his hands. Probably. I do not know.
I would like to hear statements respected forumchan on this subject.
React adequately to the criticism, no offense.
Do not be shy. Speak.
Signed in this work in Latin letters.

uriart, signature Shishkin painted with a strong inclination in the left, clearly read, letters written in simple, almost in print.
And your sample, more similar to Latin. But the signature of the Latin alphabet in Shishkina read clearly. Europeans taught.

As for me then on painting frantsiya.Podpis not clear, you can read in different ways.

Here we have no signature, but in the manner of writing to understand, SAH correctly noted. I have a collection shishkinskih sketches, in the evening at home look like.

In my opinion, the signature Shishkin is unreadable, but the signature is not important. We look forward to, when Sergei its collection look.

uriart,
I looked at material in my possession and unfortunately nothing like a Shishkina not found. Plus the fact I do not see the emphasis of his signature. "Sch ..." I saw and the signature in my opinion is not typical. My opinion - a Western painting.
And. Yuri! I never give advice and not comment on those who are "cooler" to me. I myself am learning from them. In this case you. You yourself by trial and error have a good collection of Russian and Ukrainian paintings. I have great respect for "practitioners" as opposed to "theoretical", so I ask my conclusions on your work considered "friendly correspondence":)

SergeiSK, himself a lifetime studying and never ashamed to say that it is unknown to me.
I think that the forum not only theorists but also practice. Because, and addressed the issue.
I myself do not believe that this Shishkin. But the secret hope was.
Alas, it vanished!
For all the answers thanks to all!

uriart, life Shishkina all known and all his visits to all places. For example, in 1879 (the date of submission landscape), he visited the Crimea (in conjunction with uchanikami A. Schilder, and E. Volkova) and traveled down the Volga to Samara.
And. You popodalis in the literature mention Shishkina the works on the tree?

In the literature searched. But in a living and have seen many times-2 times.
Both works Düsseldorf period, approximately the same or slightly larger size.