Makovsky, or not?
 

'll Show please!
Could this be the work of the portrait of Konstantin Makovsky?.
I would like to hear opinions from people well versed in art hudozhnika.Spasibo.

Vpolne.Portret good. At his wife Julia is similar. And the signature - not a

And her niece, too similar, and the signature, if any, can be called a signature, the type of disgusting, though old yavno.V that is the question - sort of like a visual and qualitative thing, and time is suitable and the signature of just killing, unfortunately .

And can it be a fragment of the bigger picture?

Signature 100%fake.

Yes, that signature is fake, I wrote myself in the beginning, here on speech rather than sign [for this reason it is in this section, rather than selling ....]. Message

ANTIK. and about the portrait, what opinion?

Someone with blue ribbon and the signature spoiled a good, a professional portrait.

Signatures Makovsky of the period. A portrait is really very good.

yak, and make a place, please maximize the big picture of the letter K (from signature). Especially the central part. Thank you.

Vopros ob avtorstve ne reshion. Vy predpolozili, chto kartina mozet byt 'napisana tem-to i tem-to.

Added after 2 minutes
Fal'shivaia podpis' na rabote neizvestnogo hudoznika?

Nikto ne opredelil avtorstvo raboty, a podpis' uze fal'shivaia!

Kstati, eto initsialy. V katalogah dolzno zvuchat ' "initialed" not "signed".

Added after 3 minutes
Net, vy ne sdelali utverzdeniia, chto podpis' fal'shivaia.

Added after 4 minutes
Eto vashe mnenie, no ne fakt. Komu-to bantik nravitsia.

Added after 8 minutes
Imenno takoi neprofessional'nyi podhod, mozet imet 'razlichnye negativnye posledstviia. Pri otsenke i attributsii nuzen sistematicheskii podhod. Dannaia forma ne informativna i vredna.

Eto mozet vesti k dal'neishim sporam v stile "Saryan, 1911, expert opinion from the State Tretyakov Gallery.

That's the maximum size of the big picture if you zoom in the letter - lost kachestvo.Spasibo.

Maybe like someone, I will not argue.
Imenno takoi neprofessional'nyi podhod, mozet imet 'razlichnye negativnye posledstviia. Pri otsenke i attributsii nuzen sistematicheskii podhod. Dannaia forma ne informativna i vredna.
Professional portrait, painted by Sfumato. Ie imposed in a manner Sfumato, colors as it were, dissolved in each other, not forming distinct boundaries and effecting haze. Increased tone may occur only at the touch of parts or objects.
In this portrait can be seen as mildly (tonally) fits pillow in the background and the colors are not disrupted by the method. The head girl is the center of the color and tonal composition, the eye almost in the center of the oval, but slightly shifted, which again points to the professional approach of the author. Just the eyes are the darkest spots on the picture and they are the basis of the dynamics and the illusion of life (the imaginary reality).
Bow - regardless of the method. Dramatically inscribed with the moment of fixing the image. In other words, like "nailed" to the head.
Perhaps pririsoval by the author himself after, at the request of the customer.

Of course, we can not say that the signature is fake, not knowing whose signature is and who the author works.
 One can say that the work could theoretically belong to brush Makovsky,
and the signature - is clearly not the signature Makovsky.
 Yes, place a signature, a kind of awkward.

Artiom, bantik eto tol'ko odin moment v otsenke dannoi kartiny. V otsenke dannoi kartiny net logicheskoi posledovatel'nosti iznachal'no. I imenno ob etom ia pisal.