Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство

Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/index.php)
-   Appraisal (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Two Portraits (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/showthread.php?t=40356)

Mark 28.08.2009 14:01

Two Portraits
 
Вложений: 9
Dear forum users! Maybe someone will recognize in these portraits of real historical figures? Portraits to be painted GN Gorelova.
"Bald" (provisional name): x /m, 134h112 see, in 1935;
"The Pianist" (code name): x /m, 102h135 5, 1936;
So far, my attempts to establish the accuracy of personality were not successful. For every photo> - like similar, and like not. By Order of Lenin (1934-1943gg.) And lists of awards - also disconnect, although until 1936 it was awarded a few people.
"Bald" is similar to the ID Papanina, only here the first Order of Lenin, he was awarded in 1937, but not in 1935, when the portrait was painted (can be a postscript?). A red banner he received in 1922 ...
"The Pianist" is like MN Tukhachevskogo. I received the Order of Lenin in 1933. But why is it without tabs (smeared?).
Maybe someone encountered such "historical examination" whether there are people, organizations who undertake a similar work?
Maybe some association with someone else will? I would be grateful for any tips. Our colleague Gorelov also failed to identify the work.
--------------------------------------------
On the role of the pianist has another challenger - AS Bubnov, People's Commissar of Education of the RSFSR, was shot in 1938

Кирилл Сызранский 28.08.2009 14:22

Вложений: 2
In my opinion, nor Papanina or on Tukhachevskogo characters are not like your portraits.

Allena 28.08.2009 16:26

Of course, it is not them. The forum is the grandson of GN Gorelov - gorelov. Maybe it will help you understand.

Кирилл Сызранский 28.08.2009 16:52

Allena, already seems to have addressed by topic.
Цитата:

Сообщение от Mark (Сообщение 574636)
Our colleague Gorelov, too, failed to identify the work.


Mark 28.08.2009 17:18

Цитата:

Сообщение от Allena (Сообщение 574896)
Of course, it is not they

If they were, then the topic would not have been this:)
Similarity, of course, there is a remote, but to be recognized as a great desire to be.
Special on the history, the archives said that this case is generally lethal to identify them if they were persecuted and, assume shot, because personal affairs of such people are often destroyed, and even sheets of premium black out their names. True or not - I do not know.
According to experts, is some major Soviet or party officials in those years .... And ...
I was hoping that from the subconscious that something will pop up from the people, it happens sometimes:)
And another question is raised: whether any thread of offices, which are doing this?

Кирилл Сызранский 28.08.2009 17:24

Цитата:

Сообщение от Mark (Сообщение 574986)
spice on the history, the archives said that this case is generally lethal to identify them if they were persecuted and, assume shot, because personal affairs of such people are often destroyed, and even sheets of premium black out their names. True or not - I do not know.

There is an example of how the forces forumchan was identified by one portrayed. From represirovannyh too.
http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showthread.php?t=21005

Wladzislaw 28.08.2009 17:26

Цитата:

Сообщение от Mark (Сообщение 574636)
The Pianist "(code name): x /m, 102h135 5, 1936;

Take a picture of the Order. It seems there is a flag. If so, and the dating of paintings is correct, then the upper limit should be set in 1934 (previously was another type of the Order of Lenin). TV on. portrayed was awarded the Order in 1934-1936. Going to the library, take the newspaper "Pravda" and watch the awarded the Order of Lenin and heroes of the Soviet Union, I would advise composers.

Mark 28.08.2009 17:41

Цитата:

Сообщение от Wladzislaw (Сообщение 575006)
portrayed was awarded the Order of 1934-1936

  It is this Order. As for newspapers - on the stupidity of this idea did not come:) Thanks for the advice.

Allena 28.08.2009 22:48

Цитата:

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky (Сообщение 574936)
Allena, already seems to have addressed by topic.

Quote:
Message from Mark
Our colleague Gorelov, too, failed to identify the work.

Sorry, at the end of the day reading - and looked over this phrase.

Wladzislaw, and clothing shown in the first portrait might have something to tell? I think that has a value of its blue color.

[color="# 666686"]Added after 5 minutes[/color]
Цитата:

Сообщение от Wladzislaw (Сообщение 575006)
I would advise composers

Yes, and military composers. Incidentally, there is another option: military experts "from the former, and then, unfortunately, most likely, was repressed.

Wladzislaw 29.08.2009 02:59

Цитата:

Сообщение от Allena (Сообщение 575246)
Wladzislaw, and clothing shown in the first portrait might have something to tell? I think that has a value of its blue color.

Perhaps something and then:). I do not know. Maybe see what books on naval uniform, and may not be military. Rather, all the same, something shaped, if you look at the buttons ... Any teacher ...

Mark 29.08.2009 09:52

Allena, Wladzislaw, thanks! People are also advised to try his luck, turning to the Office of Presidential Personnel and State awards. Specifically, when prompted by the Order of Lenin it worked: all data on the award, date, № etc.

Wladzislaw 29.08.2009 23:10

Цитата:

Сообщение от Mark (Сообщение 575586)
Allena, Wladzislaw, thanks! People are also advised to try his luck, turning to the Office of Presidential Personnel and State awards. Specifically, when prompted by the Order of Lenin it worked: all the data on the award, date, №, etc.

You can, of course, to shift the task to others, but do not understand why they would do what you want. If you obscure the facts of the original ...

Мимопроходил 30.08.2009 20:51

Цитата:

Сообщение от Wladzislaw (Сообщение 576)
... T. about. portrayed was awarded the Order of 1934-1936

I disagree. In parallel with the manufacture of awards for new knights, the Order of Lenin mondvor produced to replace the old type with the awardees before. By 1935, were made for the replacement of all orders up to 701 th, issued in a new form. So the author of the topic, probably have to search through the entire list. All luck!

Игорь Гурьев 19.09.2009 19:01

And in my opinion, the first picture looks like a very Papanina.


Часовой пояс GMT +3, время: 15:50.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. Перевод: zCarot