Dr. Alexander Gorbatov, "The Weather Pskov" 1915
 

Examination of the state Tretyakov gallery from November 1, 1999.
Oil on cardboard, h,5

P_Anna, sadly, but I guess not. The word for connoisseurs.
With HC.

Solovlad, will be very sad..) the Second disappointment, let's call it a day..

P_Anna, there is hope for E. M. Bebutov. Don't know creativity if not to say, do not know, but. I like the picture, I feel that there is in it now. Experts will help, will tell.
With HC.

Solovlad, and that I least wanted to leave.
Really like her work.

Agree with Solovladom.

Nothing to do with Gorbatov, and signature Petrova not similar.

Compare one of those, where he posted his real opinion.

John Preston, You don't remember what? Thanks)

Signature Petrova, but "Gorbatov" not Gorbatov.

anik, Yes, his signature, found a sample on another site.. and Found his interview where he openly admits that mistakes were made more than once.

[QUOTE=anik;3290901]Signature Petrova, but "Gorbatov" not Gorbatov@

With such a confident categorically would not assert. Very different signatures. Although anything is possible.....almost the same, people have become hostages of circumstances, though not all.
With HC.

Who Petrov and what his "expertise" market professionals know, unfortunately, very well.

[QUOTE=anik;3290971]Petrov Who is and what his "expertise" market professionals know, unfortunately, very horosho@

The fact that he is a professional expert, even to discuss objections do not want. For a very long time had to ask for help in attribution.
There could have been mistakes. This is inevitable. The rest do not want to go......
With HC.

Gorbatov or not, this is a good study.
Why oil? Visible painting with gouache or tempera on brown cardboard. Seen this basis, not grounded and without raspavshihsya oil stains. Everywhere a thin and uniform layer, this layer is not obtained even if the oil dilute with diluent...
That rainy day, also not particularly clear...
The composition is similar to the techniques Gorbatov - right large mass on the left, they are balanced verticals. But it is always possible to take note of... But these "vertical", i.e. trees, flimsy, inaccurate (see the following reference as accurately and tightly drawn trees...)
Well...

And yet. K. Gorbatov feel the state of nature, its vibration.... Here's some weakness....
With HC.

K-Maler, the material used was taken from the available expertise.
And upon closer inspection there is glitter. It seems that no tempera or gouache so doesn't show. I'm not an artist, but kept their hands in the classroom for coloring, when he studied at Lund.the Department MArchI some time ago.
The rainy mood in the work there, live for sure - and the wind blows, judging by the clothing on the figure, and the cold from her blows. The trees are really flimsy. I believe that because of their age - the younger they are, rather than at work, with which compare.
Thank You for your opinion!