Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство

Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/index.php)
-   Costs, valuation, attribution (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Painting - sketch? (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/showthread.php?t=219102)

VIA 06.10.2013 12:29

Painting - sketch?
 
Вложений: 7
Good day!

Please help evaluate the picture.
Oil on cardboard.
35h12sm.

Thank you very much for your participation!

Добавлено через 32 минуты
What is your opinion on the level of the artist?

VIA 06.10.2013 13:01

What is your opinion on the level of the artist?

Артём 06.10.2013 13:56

Цитата:

Сообщение от VIA (Сообщение 2792781)
What is your opinion on the level of the artist

VIA, regular study, conventional artist.
Without nuance, with the "grammatical errors".

VIA 07.10.2013 23:41

Thank you for your attention to the topic!)))) Can anyone would vote on the approximate cost of Studies?
It is the first page ..))

тата 08.10.2013 00:09

Цитата:

Сообщение от VIA (Сообщение 2795631)
Thank you for your attention to the topic !) ))) Can anyone would vote on the approximate cost of Studies ?)

At first sight tells me that the size ( right vertical then horizontal) 12h35 Set is not true. You have one vertical is less than two , horizontally, that is, if 12 then 22 then where , and if correct then respectively 19, 36 , 20, see the author is not present, painting a very average quality , look in the " Gelos " studies of similar size with which not how , but the author are 100-200 dollars and often do not find a buyer, unfortunately your sketch or whatever is , if you like - you keep it .

VIA 08.10.2013 00:16

He made a mistake in writing, the right size 35h21sm

Кирилл Сызранский 08.10.2013 00:23

Цитата:

Сообщение от tata (Сообщение 2795671)
then right vertical horizontal

Once again:
Цитата:

Сообщение от VIA (Сообщение 2795691)
made a mistake in writing, the right size 35h21sm


........

Сергей Дородный 08.10.2013 12:59

Etude is very decent.

But the market price even without a good sketch of authorship

will be formed on the basis of the work of unknown materials +

the artist.

Well, that is
indeed 100-200 dollars

But if it turns out that this study "good" artist

all at once make out in it his dignity.

VIA 08.10.2013 13:16

Thank you very much!
What do you think the approximate age of Studies?

Добавлено через 2 часа 1 минуту
Found on the Internet similar picture, can relate to this artist?

VIA 08.10.2013 15:17

Вложений: 5
Found on the Internet similar picture, can apply to study this artist?

Сергей Дородный 08.10.2013 18:57

Цитата:

Сообщение от VIA (Сообщение 2796201)
Thank you very much ! What do you think the approximate age Etudes ?

I, as an artist, I have the opinion of Prof. only on execution .
Opinion " amateur painting in general " - 1967-1982 .
If the artist studied in Moscow - most likely in the Stroganov ,
unnecessarily painting ( as a component of skill) at a very high level.

5 of exhibited works : Five - does not add up , and 3 - poslabzhe .
The rest - yes, may be, but so many wrote .
(2 and 4 work in general is very, very much)
Snap this sketch to a particular artist without additional disk imaging is unlikely. Well, maybe an expert from the Tretyakov could.

VIA 09.10.2013 23:26

All the works belong to the painter Tretyakov Yevgeny Ivanovich (1926-2013)

" ... In 1951, he graduated from Moscow thin. Institute . Surikov. From 1960 he taught at the Moscow art director -prom . School. Kalinin . Honored Worker of Culture of the RSFSR ( 1980 ) ... "

http://artinvestment.ru/auctions/42820

In my opinion there is similarity with the sketch works by this artist

Here are some of his other paintings : http://ola-la.livejournal.com/26586.html

What can be said about the similarity of the work ?

тата 10.10.2013 11:59

Цитата:

Сообщение от VIA (Сообщение 2798911)
All the works belong to the painter Tretyakov Yevgeny Ivanovich (1926-2013)

" ... In 1951, he graduated from Moscow thin. Institute . Surikov. From 1960 he taught at the Moscow art director -prom . School. Kalinin . Honored Worker of Culture of the RSFSR ( 1980 ) ... "

http://artinvestment.ru/auctions/42820

In my opinion there is similarity with the sketch works by this artist

Here are some of his other paintings : http://ola-la.livejournal.com/26586.html

What can be said about the similarity of work ?

Chances authorship of this sketch almost none. Just in case - such as the author himself recognizes his creation ( if alive ) . Or you will get a folder with a very similar things . A fair judge ( not a dreamer ) 'm not assume responsibility for no reason to call you a website . There are authors with a bright style and brushwork that persist in the sketches , but it's major artists and basically the first half of the twentieth century, and this work later. Well, guess what's the point , that's like me when it was in the artist Anurin , like him , and of other similar too . And the most important works of the examples , what is their size? I think they are larger , and your sketch - a picturesque blotches on the state , its purpose , grab motive lighting. Many artists have finished objects and sketches written in different ways.

camertus 10.10.2013 19:33

In my opinion no.
thing for me did not impress


Часовой пояс GMT +3, время: 06:07.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. Перевод: zCarot