Semiradsky G. (?) At auction DOROTHEUM
 

Good day, dear forum!

Interested in your opinion, what can you say to an artist's work Semiradsky G. (?), The Austrian auction on 06/05/12 DOROTHEUM lot number 182.




In advance thank you all!

A /m, 35 x 25 maintenance - EUR 46.660 Estimé EUR 4.000 - 6.000.

And what do you think about this work .....

Ilya Repin, 1914, "Mobilization" x /m, 50x70 cm

This, apparently, sketch (judging by the size), or an unfinished thing.

I have not seen this work before and have not heard even the names of such.

That's "Seeing the recruit" I know it is in the timing.
<! - ~ 1 ~ ->


A directory of trading chtotm writing, by the way?
Where a thing?

Added after 4 minutes
This, apparently, sketch (judging by the size), or an unfinished thing.

I have not seen this work before and have not heard even the names of such.

That's "Seeing the recruit" I know it is in the timing.
<! - ~ 1 ~ ->


And what is there in the auction catalog writing, by the way?
Where a thing?

It seems that he is!

Well, a lot like Ilya Repin.

How can you stand true Semiradsky with the estimate.
Well, not so much the undisputed Semiradsky cost!
Even for the auction bait is too small.
Signature I do not like.


A drawing ...
Figure!

And no one argues.

But!
Tatiana Karpova this picture in my book placed.

Added after 35 seconds
But leaving something good.
<! - ~ 1 ~ ->

Illustrated catalog of the exhibition of the academic of the 1880s would convince me more!
<! - ~ 1 ~ ->

Do you want to buy this Semiradsky on the Dorotheum, e?

Look at the letter S.
What sign is not pleased?
Yes it is.

The manner in Semiradsky really do not like , it is still a way to separate color planes is not a " front " was, as in this sketch .
And he knew how to drape a better draw.

As to the " Repin" , it is not Repin is no, but some very nablatykavshiysya comrade, perhaps quite famous.
Repin was under the influence , of course.

Strongly resembles.
His dull brown and also a sketch, not necessarily prescribe the draperies for such an approach.

Добавлено через 1 час 45 минут
And that's not exactly G.Semiradsky.
Someone came to the grandmother.



That presented above, and compare these mountain poddelschikov.

By the way, it seems that G.Semiradsky nudity from one aunt wrote.

But definitely not G.Semiradsky.
Someone has got to Grandma.



That's the one described above, and compare these pseudo poddelschikov.

By the way, it seems that G.Semiradsky nudity one aunt wrote.

Thank you for your opinion, but you can at this point , more accurate arguments, some nuances concerning this work, which could be concluded that it is not Repin ......

Slightly expanded above.

Take part in the three works Semiradsky, some are turning to the mirror image and add together.
Voila!
At the auction.
<! - ~ 1 ~ ->