Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство

Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/index.php)
-   Costs, valuation, attribution (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Is it possible that El Greco? (https://forum.artinvestment.ru/showthread.php?t=105922)

redbor 05.01.2011 22:33

Is it possible that El Greco?
 
Вложений: 1
Gentlemen, take a look, please. Image of Jesus Christ.
 In all likelihood, the work of El Greco.
 Ask the experts to clarify whether this is so.
 If the author indeed, El Greco, then where is this image and when it was written?
Thanks in advance to all.
(By the way, where to look for a good signature of El Greco?)

Seriy 05.01.2011 22:41

To me, to El Greco's too corny and correctly.

Here is a site with as complete a list of El Greco, this is no work-


http://www.el-greco-foundation.org/home-3-96-1-0.html

SAH 05.01.2011 23:39

Цитата:

Сообщение от "redbor (Сообщение 1459691)
In all likelihood, the work of El Greco.

Why him?
:)

Peter 06.01.2011 00:15

Цитата:

Сообщение от SAH (Сообщение 1459731)
Why him?
:)


It could and Russian painter napisat.Otkuda pictures?

Игорь Гурьев 06.01.2011 00:45

In the photo shows the pattern (if the picture) is about 1870-1880's, most likely a Russian school.


Type Archaeology.

Range, in general.

kr555 06.01.2011 00:48

This is definitely not El Greco.

In my work some of orthodox artist.

The Internet is found only on the Russian sites, such as

http://www.reshma.nov.ru/?out=pr_sov...r_sov_practika

http://bogistina.info/

etc.

fabosch 06.01.2011 01:16

Вложений: 1
Here is the signature of El Greco in different years.
But I think they are you do not need - is the work of the second half of 19 - beg.
20.

Тютчев 06.01.2011 07:29

Вложений: 4
Indeed this image appears on the Internet. And it is in Russian language. But an indication of authorship is not everywhere. But where it is indicated precisely by El Greco! Agree with this is simply impossible, as we have seen colleagues above. This picture can not be attributed not only to the works of El Greco himself, but also to the works of his contemporaries (the end of the 16 th - early 17 th centuries). What is also true noticed above.
 
Call a reputable network sources on which this image can not be attributed to El Greco. Judge cami:
http://forum.exler.ru/arc/index.php?...owtopic=125652
http://www.liveinternet.ru/users/itdalee/post140587062/
http://skopych.kiev.ua/2007/11/28/234/

Who went distortion is unclear. This issue just recently has been raised in another forum topic.

For the credibility of the iconography of the image of Christ hung El Greco. Here are assembled the most basic and well-known image of Jesus by an artist from private and public collections around the world. We see that the image of Christ by El Greco are changing throughout the life of the artist. But despite this we still can not call to discuss the proposed picture of his product.

Тютчев 06.01.2011 07:32

Вложений: 9
Even Jesus Christ by El Greco:

Тютчев 06.01.2011 07:34

Вложений: 4
Another Jesus by El Greco:

Тютчев 06.01.2011 07:35

Вложений: 8
And a little El Greco:

redbor 06.01.2011 13:30

Цитата:

Сообщение от Tiutchev; 1459901"
Indeed it is an image found on the Internet. And it is in Russian language.
But an indication of authorship is not everywhere. But where it is indicated precisely by El Greco!

That - anywhere author named El Greco, and no one else!
 (Example: http://blog.kp.ru/users/3617561/post124425220/ El Greco's "Head of Christ")
Apparently the error is repeated by someone dopruschennaya earlier.
But if not El Greco, who is currently a writer? Picture quite popular,
has long been known, there are reproductions and copies.
 Surely no one can know the name of the author?
 MB Vereshchagin? Or Repin? Or Makovsky?

redbor 07.01.2011 18:20

Вложений: 1
Цитата:

Сообщение от Guriev, Igor (Сообщение 1459811)
The photo shows the pattern (if the picture) is about 1870-1880's, most likely a Russian school.
Type Archaeology.
Range, in general.

Also I think - Russian artist.
Lord, art connoisseurs, please see - maybe you know?
In the lower-right corner - do not sign it? Can monogram someone?

I-V 07.01.2011 20:39

In this forum, too, trying to figure out the author's note to the post#12


http://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=...6tbs%3Disch: 1

redbor 07.01.2011 21:19

Цитата:

Сообщение от IV; 1461551"
The forum is also trying to figure out the author's note

No wonder. The image has long been known. This portrait of Jesus spent much time in the cell of the elder Sampson (Sievers graph).
Elder called him "my judge". Under this portrait he went to God.
 The author - an artist very worthy, and probably did not write this one picture ... Therefore, at various forums, and give birth to a question about the author, unanswered question ...
 But here, in fact, a special forum!
Gathered here precisely connoisseurs, and it is art!
Therefore, great hopes that someone will be able to name the author of such a wonderful portrait!
 Maybe - in the corner is, after all, a monogram? ..


Часовой пояс GMT +3, время: 23:43.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. Перевод: zCarot