A type halturka not be? For example, a gift to Mr. ?

n-t
 

Friends,

I live a few houses from the house of SV, which is now home to his granddaughter. Was there. At the forum I suggested his landscape " Moscow River near Mozhaisk " with expertise TM Levin ( TG). Of n- t of Melarusa I wrote that it was originally in critical condition (I have seen it offered to buy ). If someone does not see the difference in the manner of writing ( though, in my opinion, it is obvious) , it's not our problem. Gerasimov until recently accused of " formalism" was removed from the post of rector . Where in this still life - signs of the " formalism "?

There is a difference , but as I see, we are talking not about authorship Gerasimov , and just about certain advantages presented a still life.
For example, I watch a conversation has arisen is this shift in topic.

n-t
 

I had a few graphic signature works SV
Gerasimov

Signature clear, tough.
It was and SG
For n-even those first SA looks uncertainly.
Artist signed only completed, from his point of view, things.
N-esteem that I can not judge - is of little interest.

No.
Hack he did only in black-and- white illustrations .

Presented a still life can not even be " in a manner Gerasimov ."
It was written by an artist very sredni merits , who had studied at least the average painter. school.
Write a quick , dry, in a ragged and nervous rhythm, without any idea about it svetopostanovke : so sluggish, cold diffuse lighting.
What at SV Gerasimov never was.

He was always friendly , often almost watercolor color and oil painting almost in the manner of watercolor , often leaving small unfilled pieces of canvas (I mean still life ), wrote often transparent strokes.

This oversubscribed still life, certainly not by Sergei Gerasimov.

As for the still life, which is given to the comparison, which allegedly registered then ...
There is clearly a Korovin made, and was a student of Gerasimov Korovin.

n-t
 

I am glad that there is an understanding of the issue, does not hesitate to say - professionalism.
Korovin, Gerasimov - Russian impressionism or the Moscow School of Painting, by the way, Nina Sergeeva - continues traditions in this direction (student SV Gerasimov).

Well, 93 work with graphics, sketches, sketches and studies, and a single still life of the 93-s sovkomovskih lot and no.

But here is is:

rv
 

I'm talking about the number, which is (according to the laws of logic) gives an idea of ​​the quality.
So where there Gerasimov?

I'm sorry if this question to me, I did not understand.

signature for comparison