The Academy of Sciences ...
Posted 10-07-2013 at 14:52 by Кирилл Сызранский
At the Academy of Sciences ...
Russian Academy of Sciences is not just an affront inflicted VV Putin. First, refused to purge from corresponding members Berezovsky, as it neither requested. Second, refused to make academic Kovalchuk.
As a result, Russian Academy of Sciences stripped of their property, and at the same time and generally merged with the academies of medical and agricultural sciences - it is strange that they forgot to merge with the Academy of Natural Sciences.
The point was to crank out hastily, it was necessary to have time until the fall, because the fall will be to change the government and all the crap Medvedev should remain at the previous government.
However, regardless of the causes of the reform of the RAS, I have a number of questions to the Russian Academy of Sciences.
In 2010, a native of the city of Nizhny Tagil, Konstantin Novoselov and a native of the city of Sochi Andre Geim won the Nobel Prize in Physics. Now Novoselov and Geim are members of the Royal Society of London and the Knights - from December 31, 2011 they sir sir Geim and Novoselov.
Neither Sir Game, no sir settlers are not the academicians of RAS. They are not even corresponding members.
This year's winner Milnerovskoy Prize in Physics was Alexander Polyakov, with 1989 runs at Princeton. Polyakov was born in 1945, and in 1984 became a corresponding member of the RAS. His work on string theory are the classics of theoretical physics but Milnerovskoy Polyakov received awards in 1986 Dirac Medal and in 1994 - the Lorentz Medal, but an academician, he never became. Apparently, the move to Princeton ruined his academic career in Russia.
In the last year of the nine winners of the award Milnerovskoy three were natives of Russia.
Andrei Linde of Stanford University has been awarded for the development of the inflationary model of the universe. Linda - not an academician and corresponding member.
Alexei Kitaev at the California Institute of Technology, was awarded for the "theoretical idea of implementing robust quantum memory and fault-tolerant quantum computation using topological phases with anions and isolated Majorana modes."
China - not an academician and corresponding member.
Maxim Kontsevich (Institute of Applied Research, France), the eminent mathematician, was awarded for "the development of homological mirror symmetry, and new formulas crossing the boundaries of stability." Koncevich also Laureate of Poincare and Fields.
But he is not an academician and corresponding member.
In St. Petersburg, live asocial genius Grigory Perelman, refused the Fields Medal Prize for proving the Poincare conjecture.
Grigory Perelman - not academic and not corresponding member.
As stated in the charter of the Academy, a full member of Russian Academy of Sciences' elected scientists have enriched science scientific works of paramount importance. " Corresponding member - "scientists who have enriched science outstanding scientific work."
There are currently 531 in the Russian Academy of Sciences academician and 769 corresponding members.
We are very rich in scientific talent, is not it? We at the Academy is more than a thousand people who have enriched the science than Sir Geim, Novoselov, sir, Linde, Kontsevich and China.
Who are these wonderful people?
Meet. For example, etoViktor Ishayev, the former governor of Khabarovsk Territory, now a presidential envoy, Academician of Russian Academy of Sciences since 2008.
Plenipotentiary Ishayev, unlike some out there Linde with its inflationary model of the universe, has enriched the science of "scientific studies of the paramount importance."
Another academician, who was elected in 2011 - Boris Kuzyk, a former adviser on Kotelkina Rosvooruzheniye, the former owner of "Northern Shipyard".
In 2001, Boris Kuzyk vosmisotstranichny published a definitive work "Russia on the world arms market," presented by the reviewers as unique in terms of the depth of information and analysis of the scientific work.
Then it turned out that 99%of the materials of the book had been written off Ghostwriter Kuzyk verbatim from the site CAST, the Center for Analysis of Strategies and Technologies, we are really very good Russian military analyst Konstantin Makiyenko and Ruslan Pukhov.
We have not so much academic, and an RAS Vice-President is Alexander Nekipelov, which is a leading Russian economist (not academic, of course), Konstantin Sonin has exposed the fact that his monograph "The establishment and functioning of the economic system" charged with two outdated standard American textbooks "Microeconomics" by David Kreps and "Foundations of Economic Analysis" by Eugene Silberberga.
Maybe we'd better do Kreps and Silberberga RAS academicians as well?
When Peter was created in 1724 the Academy of Sciences, he invited her to foreigners. In Russia moved and it was working one of the greatest matematikovXVIIIv. Leonhard Euler. In the Bernoulli brothers moved to St. Petersburg, Goldbach, Mayer, Delisle, Kraft.
If Russia wants to be a great scientific power, it must do the same: it should invite foreigners. It should make them honorary members of the Academy.
Now the situation is exactly the reverse: not only do we not invite foreigners, we are great scientists of Russian origin - Polyakova, Linde, GKM, Geim, Novoselov - do not choose academics, even when they receive the Nobel, the Fields and Milnerovskuyu premium. But we academics - Ishayev, Kuzyk and Nekipelov.
And this situation is not the result of government activity. This internal problems most of Sciences, the latter a social institution that survived from the Soviet authorities.
I do not believe that the reform of the RAS should be how to do the same Kovalchuk, corresponding member of the academician, and a reward for suffering to give him ownership of the RAS.
But the problem lies in the fact that over the past 20 years, RAS has not made the slightest attempt to reform itself. She did not take to the Academy of brilliant scientists leave Russia, and did not say a word in defense of Sergei Guriev, when he had to flee from Russia. RAS outraged only when it seized property, and it makes a very weak position of the Russian Academy of Sciences.
Should dispose of the property of the Academy Academy, not Kovalchuk, Dvorkovich or Medvedev. But there must be another Academy.
Yulia Latynina
Russian Academy of Sciences is not just an affront inflicted VV Putin. First, refused to purge from corresponding members Berezovsky, as it neither requested. Second, refused to make academic Kovalchuk.
As a result, Russian Academy of Sciences stripped of their property, and at the same time and generally merged with the academies of medical and agricultural sciences - it is strange that they forgot to merge with the Academy of Natural Sciences.
The point was to crank out hastily, it was necessary to have time until the fall, because the fall will be to change the government and all the crap Medvedev should remain at the previous government.
However, regardless of the causes of the reform of the RAS, I have a number of questions to the Russian Academy of Sciences.
In 2010, a native of the city of Nizhny Tagil, Konstantin Novoselov and a native of the city of Sochi Andre Geim won the Nobel Prize in Physics. Now Novoselov and Geim are members of the Royal Society of London and the Knights - from December 31, 2011 they sir sir Geim and Novoselov.
Neither Sir Game, no sir settlers are not the academicians of RAS. They are not even corresponding members.
This year's winner Milnerovskoy Prize in Physics was Alexander Polyakov, with 1989 runs at Princeton. Polyakov was born in 1945, and in 1984 became a corresponding member of the RAS. His work on string theory are the classics of theoretical physics but Milnerovskoy Polyakov received awards in 1986 Dirac Medal and in 1994 - the Lorentz Medal, but an academician, he never became. Apparently, the move to Princeton ruined his academic career in Russia.
In the last year of the nine winners of the award Milnerovskoy three were natives of Russia.
Andrei Linde of Stanford University has been awarded for the development of the inflationary model of the universe. Linda - not an academician and corresponding member.
Alexei Kitaev at the California Institute of Technology, was awarded for the "theoretical idea of implementing robust quantum memory and fault-tolerant quantum computation using topological phases with anions and isolated Majorana modes."
China - not an academician and corresponding member.
Maxim Kontsevich (Institute of Applied Research, France), the eminent mathematician, was awarded for "the development of homological mirror symmetry, and new formulas crossing the boundaries of stability." Koncevich also Laureate of Poincare and Fields.
But he is not an academician and corresponding member.
In St. Petersburg, live asocial genius Grigory Perelman, refused the Fields Medal Prize for proving the Poincare conjecture.
Grigory Perelman - not academic and not corresponding member.
As stated in the charter of the Academy, a full member of Russian Academy of Sciences' elected scientists have enriched science scientific works of paramount importance. " Corresponding member - "scientists who have enriched science outstanding scientific work."
There are currently 531 in the Russian Academy of Sciences academician and 769 corresponding members.
We are very rich in scientific talent, is not it? We at the Academy is more than a thousand people who have enriched the science than Sir Geim, Novoselov, sir, Linde, Kontsevich and China.
Who are these wonderful people?
Meet. For example, etoViktor Ishayev, the former governor of Khabarovsk Territory, now a presidential envoy, Academician of Russian Academy of Sciences since 2008.
Plenipotentiary Ishayev, unlike some out there Linde with its inflationary model of the universe, has enriched the science of "scientific studies of the paramount importance."
Another academician, who was elected in 2011 - Boris Kuzyk, a former adviser on Kotelkina Rosvooruzheniye, the former owner of "Northern Shipyard".
In 2001, Boris Kuzyk vosmisotstranichny published a definitive work "Russia on the world arms market," presented by the reviewers as unique in terms of the depth of information and analysis of the scientific work.
Then it turned out that 99%of the materials of the book had been written off Ghostwriter Kuzyk verbatim from the site CAST, the Center for Analysis of Strategies and Technologies, we are really very good Russian military analyst Konstantin Makiyenko and Ruslan Pukhov.
We have not so much academic, and an RAS Vice-President is Alexander Nekipelov, which is a leading Russian economist (not academic, of course), Konstantin Sonin has exposed the fact that his monograph "The establishment and functioning of the economic system" charged with two outdated standard American textbooks "Microeconomics" by David Kreps and "Foundations of Economic Analysis" by Eugene Silberberga.
Maybe we'd better do Kreps and Silberberga RAS academicians as well?
When Peter was created in 1724 the Academy of Sciences, he invited her to foreigners. In Russia moved and it was working one of the greatest matematikovXVIIIv. Leonhard Euler. In the Bernoulli brothers moved to St. Petersburg, Goldbach, Mayer, Delisle, Kraft.
If Russia wants to be a great scientific power, it must do the same: it should invite foreigners. It should make them honorary members of the Academy.
Now the situation is exactly the reverse: not only do we not invite foreigners, we are great scientists of Russian origin - Polyakova, Linde, GKM, Geim, Novoselov - do not choose academics, even when they receive the Nobel, the Fields and Milnerovskuyu premium. But we academics - Ishayev, Kuzyk and Nekipelov.
And this situation is not the result of government activity. This internal problems most of Sciences, the latter a social institution that survived from the Soviet authorities.
I do not believe that the reform of the RAS should be how to do the same Kovalchuk, corresponding member of the academician, and a reward for suffering to give him ownership of the RAS.
But the problem lies in the fact that over the past 20 years, RAS has not made the slightest attempt to reform itself. She did not take to the Academy of brilliant scientists leave Russia, and did not say a word in defense of Sergei Guriev, when he had to flee from Russia. RAS outraged only when it seized property, and it makes a very weak position of the Russian Academy of Sciences.
Should dispose of the property of the Academy Academy, not Kovalchuk, Dvorkovich or Medvedev. But there must be another Academy.
Yulia Latynina
Total Comments 0
