Aivazovsky-attribution

[uriart]

Hello!

I remember the old saying Petrov V. A. on the works of Aivazovsky on the tree. In his words,was the author of works on the tree.
I would like to hear other people's opinions.
And Mr. Levenko that he will tell us about it.

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от uriart

Hello!

I remember the old saying Petrov V. A. on the works of Aivazovsky on the tree. In his words,was the author of works on the tree.

Well, Vladimir Alexandrovich, of course, know better...
It is a pity that in the timing know nothing about it.
Works by Aivazovsky "Sea ship", "moonlit night", "Calm" etc written on the tree...
You can, of course, to assume that these landscapes are all phonies. Yes, that's just grounds.
I think the final clarity will make Nikolai Levenko.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

And in TG there are two works by Aivazovsky on the tree. Their V. A. Petrov may not know.

[uriart]

Cyril Syzran, to be honest,the conversation was not with me.
It is the words of one Moscow gallerist. And it was in the mid 90-ies of the last century.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от uriart

But after that I appeared at the work of AI. on the tree. To which I reacted very serious.
And sorry!

Well, not now... [I]"out of sight - from the heart von@

[Маруся]

[QUOTE="uriart;3432571"]I will say that the conversation was not with me.
It is the words of one Moscow gallerist. And it was in the mid 90-ies of the last veka@

That's great! And articulate... But then again all my fault Petrov...

[Николай Левенко]

[QUOTE="uriart;3432461"]I Remember the old saying Petrov V. A. on the works of Aivazovsky on the tree. In his words,was the author of works on derive@

The authority of Vladimir the great, although after known exposures in the Tretyakov gallery markedly reduced. I do not want to believe that V. A. Petrov would like to say, for such a claim would be talking about the incompetence of the expert in this matter, while under the hands of Petrov passed a lot of works by Aivazovsky and he could not know that the painter, no doubt, have been working on wood, plywood and cardboard. Similar works are found in Museum and private collections. There is work done on cardboard, and in Feodosia art gallery. As a percentage of such works a bit and they are back to the second half of the master, this is the 1870 - 1900s But what Aivazovsky wrote on a solid base - this is an indisputable fact.

[uriart]

Dear Nicholas! What can you say about these works that I showed.
Will be sold at auction.

[Николай Левенко]

In the authenticity of the works You've shown I believe. Even despite the fact that the work of the "Ship in storm" too often appears in various trades (in the last decade, this is her fifth attempt), I still believe this work. Here is the approximate route of this canvas.
Christies - 30.11.2004. London. Lot No. 76. Not sold.
Christies - November 30, 2005. London. Lot No. 100. Sales results - 50 400 GBP
Then there was Koller Auctions - 2008
Later Koller Auctions - 18.09.2009 year. Zurich. Lot # 3229. with an estimate of 65 735 - 95 614 GBP and not sold again;
This year will be the fifth attempt.

[uriart]

Nikolai Levenko, Thanks a lot!
I'm not going to buy. Who cares,Vienna,Dorotheum. April 23 auction.